If the Criminal Is Unknown, Should We Punish the Crime?
Up until recent times, throughout the Near East, communities and their leaders were held responsible for crimes committed in their vicinity.
Up until recent times, throughout the Near East, communities and their leaders were held responsible for crimes committed in their vicinity.
If a corpse is found in a field, and the killer is unknown, the enders of the closest city to break a heifer’s neck by a stream and declare that they did not spill “this blood” (Deuteronomy 21). How does this ritual of eglah arufah, “broken-necked heifer,” atone for Israel’s bloodguilt?
The law of the heifer whose neck is broken, eglah arufah, has puzzled both traditional and modern commentators. What is it meant to accomplish? How does it work?