Image credits: 123rf / MS 1521, f.13v, British Library
Did God Originally Intend the World to Be Vegetarian?
In the creation story, God tells humans to eat plants. Only after the flood, does God permit them to eat animals. Interpreters have understood this to mean that vegetarianism was God’s original plan for humanity. Gersonides found the claim that God changed His mind scandalous, but this is more about countering Christian claims than the simple meaning of the text.
Published: October 16, 2020
|
Last Updated: September 7, 2026
For another discussion of the implications about primeval vegetarianism in this passage, see Yitzhaq Feder, “Meat or Murder? A Vegetarian Start,” TheTorah (2013).
This same explanation appears in a parallel passage in Genesis Rabba 34, where it is attributed to Rav’s contemporary, Rabbi Yohanan.
Many other classical commentators make the same point; see e.g., Leqah Tov, ibn Ezra (2nd commentary), Bekhor Shor, and Hizzequni.
An allusion to the language of Num 18:21.
Sefer ha-iqqarim 3:15.
Cassuto, A Commentary on the Book of Genesis, translated by Israel Abrahams (Jerusalem: Magnes, 1961), p. 58.
A Critical and Exegetical Commentary on Genesis (New York: Scribner, 1917), p. 34.
The JPS Torah Commentary: Genesis (Philadelphia: Jewish Publication Society, 1989), pp. 13-14.
חזון הצמחונות והשלום (The Vision of Vegetarianism and Peace), an essay of Rabbi Kook that originally appeared in the journal הפלס in 1903-1904. The essay has been reprinted many times since and received particular attention from Rabbi Kook’s disciple, Rabbi David Cohen (“the Nazir”; 1887–1972), who was a vegetarian. Despite claims of some modern proponents of vegetarianism, Rabbi Kook himself, notwithstanding his admiration for this ideal, was not a vegetarian. See Martin I. Lockshin, “Rav Kook Was Not a Vegetarian,” Canadian Jewish News (Aug 4, 1995); available on My Jewish Learning.
Skinner, ibid.
B. Sanhedrin 59b:
מיתיבי: ורדו בדגת הים מאי לאו לאכילה? - לא, למלאכה. - ודגים בני מלאכה נינהו? - אין, כדרחבה. דבעי רחבה: הנהיג בעיזא ושיבוטא מאי?
A contradiction: “rule the fish of the sea”—doesn’t this mean eat them? No, it means work them. But can fish be worked? Yes, as per [the implication of the question asked by] Rahava, for Rahava asked: “What is the law if one harnesses a goat and a fish?”
תא שמע: ובעוף השמים, מאי לאו לאכילה? - לא, למלאכה. - ועופות בני מלאכה נינהו? - אין, כדבעי רבה בר רב הונא: דש באווזין ותרנגולין, לרבי יוסי ברבי יהודה, מאי?
Come and hear: “and the birds of the sky”—doesn’t this mean eat them? No, it means work them. But can birds be worked? Yes, as per [the implication of the question asked by] Rabba bar Rav Huna, for Rabba bar Rav Huna asked: “If one threshed with geese and chickens, what is the law according to R. Yossi ben R. Yehudah?”
The Talmud also raises an objection from a midrash attributed to Rabbi Yehudah ben Tema that says that the angels used to roast meat for Adam to eat while he was in the Garden of Eden.
Gersonides is alluding to Guide 2:30 (p. 349 in the Pines’ translation). There, Maimonides cites “the statement, which you find formulated by some of the Sages [in Bereshit Rabba], that affirms that time existed before the creation of the world.” Maimonides calls this statement “very difficult,” and concludes, “To sum up, you should not, in considering these points, take into account the statements made by this one or that one.” In the medieval translation of the Guide into Hebrew, this phrase is translated as סוף דבר לא תביט באלו המקומות למאמר אומר, almost the exact wording that Gersonides employs here.
In his commentary to Gen 8:4, Nahmanides writes that at times midrashim offer mutually exclusive ideas. He then concludes, albeit more gently than Gersonides, that for this reason we need not see every midrash as authoritative.
See Mark 7:19, for example. Whether or not this understanding of the original meaning of this passage in Mark is correct, by Gersonides’ days it was the common Christian understanding of this text and others in the New Testament.
In the continuation of Gersonides’ comment, he explains that God can change His mind to make rules stricter, but that making them more lenient was not a logical possibility. Albo disagrees: see Sefer ha-Iqqarim 3:14 and 3:15.
See the introductory essay to my Rashbam’s Commentary on the Torah: An Annotated Translation (Providence: Brown Judaic Studies, 2004), 19–22. See also Yedida Eisenstat, “Does Rashi's Torah Commentary Respond to Christianity?” TheTorah (2018); and Shaye J. D. Cohen, “The Torah Is not an Allegory,” TheTorah (2018).
In some censored texts of Maimonides’ Mishneh Torah, the words “like the Christians and Muslims” are missing. They are found in the more reliable manuscripts and editions.
MT, Hilkhot Teshuvah 3:8.