The Reconciliation of Jacob and Esau, Flemish school, c. 1600 (detail). Wikimedia
Esau the Ancestor of Rome
In the Bible, Esau is the ancestor of the Edomites who live on Mount Seir, southwest of Judah. So how did the rabbis come to associate Esau and Edom with Rome? Two main factors are at work here: Christianity and Herod.
Published: November 7, 2018
|
Last Updated: November 11, 2026
For more on this, see Marvin A. Sweeney, “Israel’s History as a Family Narrative,” TheTorah (2015). Other biblical passages explain these names differently: Esau is called Edom because he asked Jacob for some “red stuff” to eat (Gen 25:30); Mount Seir is so named because it is where a man named Seir the Horite lived (Gen 36:20-30) before the Edomites conquered the area from the Horites and made it their own (Deut 2:12, 22).
For some discussion of this in the context of Hebron and its archaeological finds, see David Ben-Shlomo, “The Ancient City of Hebron,” TheTorah (2018).
For more on this, see David Freidenreich, “What Does Sarah’s Expulsion of Hagar Signify for Abraham’s Descendants?” TheTorah (2018); Samuel Z. Glaser, “Isaac’s Divine Conception,” TheTorah (2017).
See also his, On the Soul, 26.2.
Translation is taken from, Jeffrey D. Dunn, Tertullian (The Early Church Fathers; New York: Routledge, 2004), 69-70.
The phrase in brackets appears in the Theodor-Albeck edition but not in the standard printing. It was likely skipped over by a copyist whose eyes can often jump from וזה to וזה (homeoteleuton). As many commentators only had access to the standard printing for years, the classic interpretation of the passage with the missing line was that whereas Israel is proud of its place in the world to come, Rome was proud of its accomplishments in this world.
The midrash is based on a ketiv-qere—when a word is written one way but pronounced another way—in God’s message to Rebekah when she is pregnant (Gen 25:23, quoted above). The word in question is read גוים, “nations,” but is written as גיים, which can be understood as an alternative spelling for גאים, meaning, “proud people.”
This Antoninus appears in the Talmud as a Roman king and beloved friend of Rabbi Yehudah HaNasi (Judah the Prince). Scholars debate whether Antoninus is meant to represent a real historical figure (Antoninus Pius), but all agree that the conversations between him and Rabbi Yehudah HaNasi are legendary.
Judea had one further brief stint as a client state, when Herod’s grandson Agrippa I ruled in 41-44 C.E.
For more on the rabbis’ view of Herod, see Jeffrey Rubenstein, “Herod’s Renovation of the Temple: The Talmudic Version,” TheGemara (2017); Ibid., “Herod’s Renovation of the Temple: Uncovering the Talmud’s Persian Influences,” TheGemara (2017).
See Malka Simkovich, “Queen Berenice: A Woman of Contrasts,” TheTorah (2016).
Abraham ibn Ezra, commentary to Isaiah 63:1.