Is the Recent Antipathy to Joseph Justified?

Contemporary abuse of a once popular biblical hero.

SBL Style

Click to copy

"Is the Recent Antipathy to Joseph Justified?." TheTorah.com, January 2, 2017. https://www.thetorah.com/article/is-the-recent-antipathy-to-joseph-justified.

APA Style

Click to copy

"Is the Recent Antipathy to Joseph Justified?" (2017, January 2). TheTorah.com. https://www.thetorah.com/article/is-the-recent-antipathy-to-joseph-justified

Is the Recent Antipathy to Joseph Justified?

Joseph, Overseer of Pharaoh’s Granaries, 1874.  Sir Lawrence Alma-Tadema, Dutch/British.

Categories:

Vayigash

Published: January 2, 2017

|

Last Updated: September 7, 2026

  1. Even before Genesis Rabbah filled in every nook and cranny of Torah’s account, Second Temple texts such as Joseph and Asenat, Testament of Twelve Patriarchs, Philo (twice!), and Jubilees write their own versions of Joseph’s life story. Flavius Josephus saw his biblical namesake as the epitome of Roman Virtu, and the identification of Joseph as the subject of the “the sale of the righteous” in Amos 2:6 presumably sparked that choice for the haftarah reading. 

  2. Gerhard von Rad, Wisdom in Israel (Nashville: Abingdon, 1972); Von Rad, “The Joseph Narrative and Ancient Wisdom,”The Problem of the Hexateuch and Other Essays (Edinburgh, 1966), 292. See Yigal Levin, “The Benjamin Conundrum,” ZAW16:2 (2004): 223-241, for a recent survey of the different genre-categories to which Joseph has been assigned.

  3. The word eretz/aratzot appears eight times in this pericope, seventeen times in Gen 41, focusing readers’ attentions on the inability to get sustenance from any other land.

  4. Berel Dov Lerner argued that Gen 41 displays Joseph as God’s agent, Genesis 47 as a self-aggrandizing despot. See, Berel Dov Lerner, “Joseph the Unrighteous,” Judaism: A Quarterly Journal 38:1 (1989): 278-281.    

  5. Just to offer a sense of proportion, this unit is the same size as the entire Cain and Abel story.

  6. Ironically, Samuel was much less charitable to Joseph with regard to his treatment of his brothers. Samuel calls Joseph a “brilliant failure,” morally speaking, describing him as a figure who could not forgive his brothers’ aggression and could not overcome his own self-importance.

  7. Maurice Samuel, “The Brilliant Failure,” Certain People of the Book (NY: Knopf, 1955), 244-345. Samuel correctly characterizes, but ultimately rejects, the ironic view of Joseph presented in Thomas Mann’s Joseph and His Brothers.

  8. I believe temiyah and hitbollelut are the most common modern Hebrew words for assimilation.

  9. Certainly, Joseph’s Egyptianization differs from the situation imagined by the midrash for the Hebrews in the exodus account, in which they maintain their distinct ethnic identities insofar as their names, language, and clothing (See:Tanna DeBei Eliyahu 23:4). The idea that this threesome functions as a tool for preserving Jewish identity re-emerged as a creed of ultra-Orthodoxy in the 19th century.

  10. Aaron Wildavsky, The Nursing Father: Moses as a Political Leader; Wildavsky, Assimilation versus Separation:. Joseph the Administrator and the Politics of Religion in Biblical Israel (New Brunswick NJ: Transaction Books, 1993), 138-139.

  11. Wildavsky, Assimilation versus Separation, 1.

  12. Granted, Moses’ name is Egyptian in origin, but etiology often trumps etymology in the Bible. Pharaoh’s daughter, speaking imperfect Hebrew, names the infant Moses because, “I drew him out of the water” (Exodus 2:10). That said, Moses’ name reflects a dual Hebrew-Egyptian identity, unlike Joseph, who is called Zaphenat Paneah exactly once. Moreover, the exodus narrative does not make sense without assuming some level of familiarity with Egyptian ways on Moses’ part. Finally, both marry non-Israelite wives, and this becomes a problem for Moses (Num. 12) though not for Joseph.

  13. “Assimilation,” the inevitable shedding of foreign elements by an immigrant, and “assimilationism,” an ideology that this phenomenon is a positive good, ought to be distinguished.

  14. Joseph was able to avoid this occurring during his lifetime. Indeed, the infamous verse, “And a new king arose who knew not Joseph” (Exod. 1:8) casts the censure on the Pharaoh of oppression, not on Joseph. Nevertheless, several narrative touches in Genesis 48-50 point toward this deterioration having begun in Joseph’s lifetime. The features that darken Gen 48-50 include: 1) holding hostage of the family during Jacob’s funeral cortege, 2) the contrasting lack of ceremony attending Joseph’s own burial, 3) the tone and address Joseph uses to ask permission to bury Jacob, 4) the apparent acknowledgement by Joseph that the time remaining in Egypt for Israel will be lengthy. Joseph ultimately ruled for eighty years, from age 30 to age 110. For those inclined to take biblical numbers as more symbolic than arithmetic, one could calculate this tenure as two whole generations, or more loosely, a very long time.

  15.  Moses Pava, “Joseph and the Use of Inside Information: An Exploration of the Joseph Narrative,” Torah U’Madda Journal 4 (1993), 134-147, esp. 141. Robert Sacks, A Commentary on the Book of Genesis (Lewiston, NY: Edwin Mellen Press, 1990), 400-401, presents Joseph’s agrarian policies as not just a counterpoint to Israel’s laws, a point on which Benno Jacob and Nehama Leibowitz agree, but also as a negative ethical verdict on Joseph. 

  16. Ivan Caine, “Numbers in the Joseph Narrative,” Jewish Civilization: Essays & Studies(ed. R.A. Brauner; RRCP 1; Philadelphia: Reconstructionist Rabbinical College Press, 1979), 9 -10. Caine maintains the historicity of this description of Egypt’s circumstances has no bearing on the negative portrayal of Joseph. For a contrary reading, see B. Jacob, The First Book of the Bible, pp. 318-319:

    Indignation because of the people and the land of Egypt falling into dependency is misplaced. Joseph does not demand their subordination but the Egyptians offer it. This is the true intention of the whole story. The book of Genesis is intended… as an introduction to Exodus.
  17. See Aviva Zornberg, Genesis. The Beginning of Desire (Philadelphia: JPS, 1995). pp. 286-290 for her insightful remarks on these names.

  18. See esp. Ben Sirach: “Nor was anyone ever born like Joseph; even his bones were cared for” (49:15) and Mishnah Sotah 1:9, “Joseph was the one who was found worthy to bury his father Jacob: and there were none among the brothers greater than him – as it is said, “And Joseph went up to bury his father, and there went up with him chariots and riders. Who then was greater than Joseph? Moses was the one who took care of him, as it is said, “And Moses took Joseph’s bones with him.” Who then do you have greater than Moses who might in his turn bury him? God himself was the one who took care of his remains, as it is said “And He buried him in Valley but no man knows the place of his burial to this day.” For a brilliant study of this tradition, see James Kugel, In Potiphar’s House (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1990), 13-27.

  19. Ludwig Rosenthal, “Die Josephsgeschichte mit den Büchern Esther und Daniel verglichen” ZAW (1895): 278-284; Moshe Gan, “The Scroll of Esther in Light of Events of Joseph in Egypt.” Tarbiz 1961 (144-149). Other scholars have built upon these seminal articles; limitations of space preclude a fuller discussion.

  20. Hazony, The Dawn: Political Teachings of the Book of Esther (Jerusalem: Shalem, 1990); See also, Wildavsky,Assimilation versus Separation, 126-129. Hazony’s negative stance towards Joseph is even clearer in his comparison between Joseph and Abraham in his ambitious work, The Philosophy of Hebrew Scriptures (NY: Cambridge University Press, 2012), in which he presents Joseph as someone who trades away his progeny’s independence from the Egyptian imperial system for a mess of potage.

  21. Nehama Leibowitz, New Studies in Genesis (Jerusalem: Hemed Press, 1954-1966), Miketz 1, 439-442.

Related Topics:JosephDaniel