Esau Meeting Jacob (detail, adapted), 1881, Dalziel Brothers. Metmuseum.org
Why Is Esau’s Kiss Dotted?
Esau’s kiss to Jacob is written with scribal dots over the word וַׄיִּׄשָּׁׄקֵ֑ׄהׄוּׄ, “and he kissed him.” Traditional commentators suggest this hints to Esau’s feelings or state of mind. Critical scholarship, however, points to something much more prosaic, a question of syntax.
Published: November 19, 2018
|
Last Updated: September 7, 2026
Genesis 33:4 is one of the ten places dotted in the Torah. The basic presentation of the topic of the significance of dotted letters in the Torah remains Saul Lieberman, “The Ten Dotted Places in the Torah,” Hellenism in Jewish Palestine (New York, 1962), 43-46. Manuscripts from Qumran have added further evidence, but not changed the basic picture. See further Emanuel Tov, Scribal Practices and Approaches Reflected in the Texts Found in the Judean Desert (Leiden, 2009), 175-186; ibid., “(Proto-)Masoretic Text: Scribal Marks,”TheTorah.com (2017).
Shemaryahu Talmon, “Prolegomenon,” in Romain F. Butin, The Ten Nequdoth of the Torah (Baltimore: J.H Furst, 1906; New York: Ktav, 1969 Reprint), xxi-xxviii.
An alternative text, והלכה בידוע “it is a known rule,” which was known to Rashi and thus became the dominant reading, led to much speculation about why this is a “rule.” See discussion in Martin Lockshin, “Esau Hates Jacob But Is Antisemitism a Halakha?” TheTorah (2016).
References to Rabbinic sources that follow are to the page numbers in the standard critical editions: Sifre Numbers – Kahana; Genesis Rabbah – Theodor-Albeck; Mekhilta de-Rabbi Yishmael – Horovitz-Rabin; Avot of Rabbi Nathan [ARN] – Schechter.
He was of the first generation of amoraim in the Land of Israel, roughly the first half of the third century C.E.
According to the version of the event as told in the first printed edition of Genesis Rabbah, as recorded in the critical apparatus of Theodor-Albeck (vol. 2, p. 927), Jacob’s neck became like marble and Esau broke his teeth on Jacob’s neck. Jacob then cried over his neck while Esau cried over his broken teeth. From the first printed edition this account of the consequences of Esau’s kiss was then repeated in popular (vulgate) versions of Genesis Rabbah such as the Vilna edition, as Albeck commented ad loc.:וכן הדפיסו אחריו “and thus was it printed after this.”
Despite the authority of the Rabbis, Ibn Ezra rejected the midrashic interpretation of the verse:
הדרש על נקודות וישקהו טוב הוא לעתיקי משדים כי על דרך הפשט לא חשב עשו לעשות רע לאחיו והעד, ויבכו, כאשר עשה יוסף עם אחיו.
The derash explaining the dots on the word “he kissed him” is good for babes newly weaned, since, according to its simple meaning, Esau did not plan on doing any harm to his brother. Note, [the verse says] “and they cried” just as Joseph did with his brothers.
Ibn Ezra, however, did not offer his own explanation of why וישקהו was dotted. Compare Nahum Sarna, The JPS Torah Commentary Genesis בראשית (Philadelphia, 1989), 366, n. 3, who adopted the midrashic explanation of the verse known from Origen and the Rabbis.
The columns were:
- Hebrew;
- Transliteration of the Hebrew into Greek letters;
- LXX;
- Aquila;
- Symmachus;
- Theodotion.
In addition to simply putting the various versions in columns, Origen also marked what was in Hebrew but not in the LXX as well as marking what was in the LXX but not in the Hebrew.
The most convenient edition remains that of Fridericus Field, Origenis Hexaplorum quae Supersunt (Oxford, 1875). It is available as a pdf on the Internet at https://archive.org/details/origenhexapla01unknuoft. I note, however, that a new edition is being prepared under the auspices of the Hexapla Institute, as described at www.hexapla.org.
Mē anaginōskētai, which means not to be read at all, to be skipped as a spurious reading. This is not a matter of ketiv/qere.
Field, in his edition of Origen’s Hexapla, 49, n. 6. Field cited five MSS. Codd. Regii in his work, 4-5, all in the “royal” library of Paris. He did not specify which of the five were the two that had this anonymous comment.
As one example: when the Red Sea was split a separate path through the waters was carved for each tribe, as noted by Origen in Hom. In Ex, 5. and by the Rabbis in Mekhilta de Rabbi Yishmael, 100. R. Heine, Origen, Homilies on Genesis and Exodus (Washington, 1982), 283, n. 58. On Origen and the Rabbis in more general terms see Reuven Kimelman, “Rabbi Yokhanan and Origen on the Song of Songs: A Third-Century Jewish-Christian Disputation,” HTR 73 (1980): 567-595.
This explanation of the origin of dotted letters suggests that there was not one organized body, practicing one consistent textual policy, behind the dotted letters. This presumption may explain the fact that the reasons for some dotted letters in the Torah are hard to determine. See for example the dots in Deut 29:28 on לנו ולבנינו ע which Tov, Scribal Practices, 204, considered cryptic and Talmon, “Prolegomenon,” xviii, deemed “extremely enigmatic.” Editor’s note: For a solution to this problem, see the author’s subsequent essay: “Dots on Deuteronomy 29:28: A Polemical Response to Qumran’s Secret Laws,” TheTorah (2020).
As quoted by Lieberman, Hellenism, 44, n. 52. For the use of dots as marks for omission in Classical texts, see Tov, Scribal Practices, 184.
For some examples, see his, “(Proto-)Masoretic Text: Scribal Marks,” TheTorah (2017).
Tov, Scribal Practices, 202.
I follow Tov because he wrote some forty years after Talmon and his conclusion was based on knowledge of a far wider corpus of texts.
In Avot of Rabbi Nathan B, 98, col. b, Ezra’s explanation to Elijah was introduced with the question: ולמה נקוד על כל האותיות האלה? Judah Goldin, The Fathers According to Rabbi Nathan, Yale Judaica Series 10 (New Haven: Yale University Press, 1956), 139 inserted this question into the shorter text of ARNA cited above as supplying a context for Ezra’s answer to Elijah.
In Numbers 3:5 Moses was commanded to “bring forward the Levites” (הקרב את בני לוי), and the rest of chapter continues with the account of how this was done. However, at the end, summarizing the counting of the Levites, we find:
במדבר ג:לט כָּל פְּקוּדֵ֙י הַלְוִיִּ֜ם אֲשֶׁר֩ פָּקַ֙ד מֹשֶׁ֧ה וְ֗אַ֗הֲ֗רֹ֛֗ן֗ עַל פִּ֥י יְ־הוָ֖ה לְמִשְׁפְּחֹתָ֑ם...
Num 3:39 All the Levites who were recorded, whom at YHWH’s command Moses and Aaron recorded by their clans...
Not surprisingly, ואהרן (“and Aaron”) is dotted. What was he doing there, as the original command was given to Moses alone!? This difficulty was recognized in Sifre Numbers 69, where the dots were explained as indicating a problem word שלא היה במיניין “since he wasn’t part of the counting.” The standard printing reads differently, שלא היה אהרן מן המנין “Aaron was not one of the [Levites who were] counted.” Menachem Kahana suggested that this might have been a deliberate attempt to adjust the more controversial claim to something less problematic. See Menachem Kahana, ספרי במדבר: מהדורה מבוארת [Sifre on Numbers: An Annotated Edition] (Jerusalem: Magnes, 2011), 4.475-476.
One modern scholar, Wilhem Vischer, “La Réconciliation de Jacob et d’Esaü,” Verbum Caro 11/41 (1957): 41-51 [p. 47], wanted to have it both ways. He noted the dots on וַׄיִּׄשָּׁׄקֵ֑ׄהׄוּׄ as both cancellation dots and as the basis for the Midrash on the evils of Esau but rejected both. Accepting these explanations is “c’est passer devant la vérité sans la voir. Tout le récit est clair et net et ne permet aucun doute.” For Vischer, the reconciliation of Jacob and Esau was real, a prefiguration of the total, universal, and cosmic reconciliation achieved by Jesus on the cross. This Christological interpretive context is consistent with the indication, ibid, 41, n. 1 that Vischer’s paper was based on remarks delivered at the European Regional Assembly of the International Reform Alliance in Emden in August 1956.
Butin, Ten Nequdoth, 74, suggested that this was the reading behind the Hebrew source of the major archetype of the verse in the LXX. The connection with the LXX version was a principal reason Talmon also preferred this explanation of the dotted letters, “Prolegomenon,” xii-xiii. For Tov’s comments on the LXX version of this verse see Tov, Scribal Practices, 203, n. 268.
Butin, Ten Nequdoth, 74.
My interpretation differs from that offered by other scholars, such as by Lajos Blau, Masoretische Untersuchungen (Strassburg, 1891), 22, and Christian David Ginsburg; Introduction to the Massoretico-Critical Edition of the Hebrew Bible (London, 1897), 325 in insisting on recognizing the idiom for kissing and crying in Gen 45:15 and the difficulty it caused for our verse in comparison to the idiom for crying while falling on someone’s neck, as in Gen 45:14. Compare also Ephraim A. Speiser, Genesis (New York, 1964), 259 who cited an Akkadian parallel for falling on someone’s neck and kissing them, and therefore concluded that there was no problem in the verse. Again, however, Speiser did not note that the reason וַׄיִּׄשָּׁׄקֵ֑ׄהׄוּ was problematic was that it introduced a second idiom for crying (missing altogether in his Akkadian parallel) into a verse that already utilized another idiom for crying.
I note with pleasure that Talmon conceded that Butin’s interpretation “indeed has some appeal,” even if Talmon found its reasoning precarious since he was convinced that the sequence in Gen 45:14-15 showed that the two idioms could co-exist and did not clash. Talmon, “Prolegomenon,” xii-xiii.
Perhaps, as suggested to me by the editors, this act of kissing and crying was seen differently because Joseph was kissing his dead father. It was a kiss of goodbye, closure after crying. Cf. the idiom in Gen 46:29, above, where Joseph fell on Jacob’s neck and wept on his neck some more.
For some reflections on this dissonance, see, “Not a Naive Reading: An Interview with Professor James Kugel,” TheTorah (2018).