Moses Maimonides with his father, Rabbi Maimon, and his son, R. Abraham. AI
Kosher Torah Text? Three Generations of Maimonides—Strict to Lenient
Rabbi Maimon, Moses Maimonides’ father, believed that the Torah’s exact wording and layout had been divinely dictated to Moses down to the smallest detail—including paragraph divisions (open vs. closed), spelling (defective vs. plene), and even the decorative taggin atop certain letters. Maimonides, despite his rationalist philosophy, largely maintained this stringent view, though he would not invalidate a Torah scroll due to missing taggin. His son, R. Abraham, further relaxed the requirements as the realities of medieval manuscripts made the older standards untenable.
Published: September 4, 2026
|
Last Updated: October 28, 2026
See discussion in Emanuel Tov, “The Torah Scroll: How the Copying Process Became Sacred,” TheTorah (2023).
The text reads:
בבלי שבת קג: שלא יכתוב לאלפין עיינין ולעיינין אלפין, ביתין כפין כפין ביתין, גמלין צדין צדין גמלין, דלתין רישין רישין דלתין, היהין חיתין חיתין היהין, ווין יודין יודין ווין, זיינין נונין נונין זיינין, פיפין טתין טיתין פיפין,
b. Shabbat 103b You should not write an aleph as an ayin or an ayin as an aleph; a bet as a kaf or a kaf as a bet; gimmel as a tzadi or a tzadi as a gimmel; a dalet as a resh or a resh as a dalet; a heh as a chet or a chet as a heh; a vav as a yod or a yod as a vav; a zayin as a nun or a nun as a zayin; a peh as a tet or a tet as a peh;
פשוטין כפופין כפופין פשוט[י]ן, מימין סמכין סמכין מימין, סתומין פתוחין פתוחין סתומין,
A straight letter bent or a bent letter straight; a [final] mem as a samekh or a samekh as a [final] mem; a closed [mem] as an open [mem] or an open [mem] as a closed [mem].
All translations are mine.
The commentary survives only for some tractates and in fragments.
That this is the origin of the gloss is stated explicitly in a line at the end of the passage as quoted in Or. 491, which includes Maimonides commentary on Tractate Rosh Hashanah, and the gloss on Abaye’s statement in b. Megillah at the end:
כך פי' רבי' מיימון שלמד מפי רבו רבי' יוסף הלוי ז"ל.
Thus explained Our Rabbi Maimon, who learned it from the mouth of his teacher, Our Rabbi Joseph HaLevi [ibn Miggash] of blessed memory.
See Ephraim Kupfer, “בדבר מחברו של פירוש קדמון על מימרא דאביי במגילה לא, ב” [With Regard to the Author of the Ancient Commentary on the State of Abaye in Megillah 31b], Sinai 59 (1966): 295.
The gloss is in response to Abaye’s comment that Moses phrased the curses in Deuteronomy on his own. Abaye distinguishes between the curses in Leviticus, which are in the plural, in God’s own words, and those of Deuteronomy, which are in the singular, and phrased by Moses. The comment is glossing the rule that one may not stop in the middle of the curses in a public reading:
בבלי מגילה לא: [הספרייה הבריטית 400] א[מר] אביי: "לא שנו אלא קללות שבתורת כהנים אבל של משנה תורה פוסק." מאי טע[מא]? אמ[ר] אביי: "הללו בלשון רבים אמורין ומשה מפי הגבורה אמרן, והללו בלשון יחיד אמורים ומשה מפי עצמו אמרן."
b. Megillah 31b [BL 400] Abaye said: “This was only taught regarding the curses in Leviticus, but those of Deuteronomy, he may stop.” What is the reason? Abaye said: “These [in Leviticus] are expressed in the [2nd person] plural, and Moses stated them from God, but these [in Deuteronomy] are expressed in the [2nd person] singular, and Moses stated them on his own.”
The text is from Simha Assaf, “פירוש מסכת מגילה המיוחס לרמב"ם” [The Commentary on Tractate Megillah Attributed to Maimonides] Sinai 6 (1970), 129–132. When Assaf first published this fragment decades earlier, he did not know this was from Maimonides and simply included it as an anonymous fragment in his compendium. See Simha Assaf, מספרות הגאונים: תשובות הגאונים ושרידים מספרי ההלכה מתוך כתבי-יד של ה״גניזה׳׳ ומקורות אחרים [Gaonic Responsa and Fragments of Halachic Literature from the Geniza and other Sources], תורתן של גאונים וראשונים א [Rabbinic Texts and Documents I: Gaonica] (Darom, 1933), pp. 199–200. As quotes of this passage were found in different manuscripts and published by other scholars, Assaf realized it was from the lost commentary of Maimonides and republished it as such, this time using multiple manuscripts.
The midrash about the 2,000 years appears in several collections, the earliest of which appears to be Genesis Rabbah, in the context of Rabbi Chama bar Chaninah’s statement that the creatures or beings created on each of the 6 days of creation would ask the ones created the day before what happened:
בראשית רבה (וילנא) ח:ב לראשון למי היו שואלין לא לתורה שקדמה לברייתו של עולם, דאמר ר' ש[מעון] בן לקיש: "שני אלפים שנה קדמה התורה לברייתו של עולם, ה[דא] ה[וא] ד[כתיב] (משלי ח:ל) 'ואהיה אצלו אמון [ואהיה שעשועים יום יום],' ויומו של הקדוש ברוך הוא אלף שנים, דכתיב (תהלים צ:ד): 'כי אלף שנים בעיניך כיום אתמול...'"
Gen Rab (Vilna) 8:2 And [that which was created on] day one, who would it ask? Not the Torah, which predated the creation of the world? As R. Shimon ben Lakish said: “The Torah predates the creation of the world by two thousand years, as it says (Prov 8:30): ‘I was with [God] as a confidant, a source of delight every day.” And a day for the Blessed Holy One is a thousand years, as it says, “for a thousand years in your eyes is like yesterday”...
In addition to the Genesis Rabbah text quoted below, see also Leviticus Rabbah 19:1; Song Rabbah 5:1, Pesiqta deRav Kahana 12; Midrash Tanchuma (Buber) Yitro 16; Midrash Tanchuma (Warsaw) Veyeshev 4; Midrash Shmuel 5:2; Midrash “Hashem BeChochmah Yasad Aretz” (Eisenstein, Otzar Midrashim p. 104); Midrash Aseret HaDibrot (Eisenstein, Otzar Midrashim p. 452); Midrash Pinchas ben Yair (Eisenstein, Otzar Midrashim p. 476).
The text in the Theodor-Albeck edition is slightly different and does not mention Resh (=R. Shimon ben) Lakish:
בראשית רבה (תיאודור-אלבק) בראשית פרשה ח' ...וא' למי היה שואל? לא לתורה אתמהא שקדמה היא לברייתו שלעולם [אלפים שנה]? ה[דא] ה[וא] ד[כתיב] (משלי ח:ל): "ואהיה אצלו אמון ואהיה שעשועים יום יום" ויומו שלהקב"ה אלף שנים שנ[אמר] (תהלים צ:ד): "כי אלף שנים בעיניך כיום אתמול"...
Gen Rab (Theodor-Albeck) Bereishit §8 ...And [that which was created on] day one, who would it ask? Not the Torah, which predated the creation of the world [by two thousand years]? As it says (Prov 8:30): “I was with [God] as a confidant, a source of delight every day.” And a day for the Blessed Holy One is a thousand years, as it says (Ps 90:4), “for a thousand years in your eyes is like yesterday”...
Nevertheless, the statement is attributed to Resh Lakish in many (though not all) of the other references to this midrash. The Theodor-Albeck text is likely the result of a parablepsis of the homoioteleuton “identical endings” variety, skipping from one לברייתו שלעולם to the next.
As Maimonides is quoting his father verbatim here, it is likely that this is Rabbi Maimon referring to his own writings, many of which are no longer extant.
He continues:
וכדאמ[רינן] ראויה היתה פ' מקלל שתכתב על ידי משה אלא מגלגלין זכות על ידי זכאי וחובה על ידי חייב.
and as we said, the passage about the man who cursed God was worthy of being written by Moses, but we bring forth merit through the meritorious and fault through the blameworthy.
וכך נמצאת אמר שש מאות ושלש עשרה מצות הם שהיו.
And thus one must say that there were 613 commandments that were [already written into the Torah from the beginning].
He then brings a prooftext from Genesis Rabbah, noting that the geography is also part of the preexisting Torah, even though the world had not yet been formed:
וכדתניא ב[בראשית] דר' אושעיה בפ[רשת] בראשית (בראשית רבה טז:ב): "'הוא הסובב את כל ארץ החוילה' (בראשית ב:יא), ועדיין לא עמדה, ואת אמר הוא הסובב את כל ארץ החוילה, אתמהא?! אלא מגיד [מראשית אחרית." וכן] נמי תנן: "'הוא ההולך קדמת אשור', עדיין לא עמד אשור [ואת אמר הוא ההולך קדמת אשור] אתמהא?! אלא מגיד מראשית אחרית." הנה למדתה שהי[ו יחוסי אומות כתובין וכל שכן ישראל] המיוחסין.
And as it was taught in Genesis of Rabbi Oshaya (=Genesis Rabbah), in the parasha of Bereishit (Gen Rab 16:2): “‘The one that winds through the whole land of Havilah’ (Gen 2:11)—but it doesn’t yet exist and you say it winds through the whole land of Havilah?! Rather ‘it foretells the end from the beginning’ (Isa 46:10). And similarly, we were taught (idem) “‘The one that flows east of Assyria’ (Gen 2:14)—Assyria wasn’t founded yet, and you say it flows east of Assyria?! Rather ‘it foretells the end from the beginning’ (Isa 46:10).” Thus, you learned that the genealogy of the nations was written, and how much more so that of Israel, whose lineage is important.
In his introduction to the Mishneh Torah, Maimonides claims that Rabbi Hoshaya/Oshaya was the author of Genesis Rabbah, because the opening midrash in Genesis Rabbah is recorded in the name of R. Oshaya:
רמב"ם הקדמה למשנה תורה רבי הושעיא תלמידו של רבינו הקדוש חיבר ביאור ספר בראשית.
Maimonides Intro to Mishneh Torah Rabbi Hoshaya, the student of Our Holy Rabbi (=R. Judah HaNasi) composed a commentary to the book of Genesis.
Nevertheless, scholars date the text to the 5th century, two centuries after this 3rd century figure.
The Masoretic Text (MT) of the Hebrew Bible contains numerous examples of texts that are written one way but are meant to be read out loud a different way. The phenomenon is referred to as Ketiv-Qeri (כתיב-קרי), meaning, the “written” version (ketiv) and the publicly “read” version (qeri).
The text reads:
וכך נמי יש דברים [שאמר ה]קב"ה למשה לכתבן כאלו הקב"ה מדבר עם יש[ראל] שלא על ידי שליח, כגון "אנכי יי' אלהיך אשר הוצאתיך", וכגון קללות דתורת כהנים (ויקרא כו) [דכתי' בהו: ...... "והלכתי עמכם" (כד, כח) "והפקדתי עליכם" (טז) "והבאתי עליכם" (כה, לו, מא)],
So too, there are things that the Blessed Holy One told Moses to write as if the Blessed Holy One were speaking with the Israelites, without an intermediary, such as (Exod 20:2; Deut 5:6) “I am the LORD your God who took you out…” And like the curses in Leviticus (ch. 26) as it states in them “I will treat you” (vv. 24, 28), “I will wreak upon you” (v. 16), “I will bring upon you” (vv. 25, 36, 41).
[וכן נמי] דברים שאמר הקב"ה למשה לכתבן כאלו הקב"ה מדבר עם משה מה שהוא עושה לישראל. כגון (ויקרא כו:מג) "יען וביען במשפטי מאסו וכו'."
And so too, with things that the Blessed Holy One told Moses to write as if the Blessed Holy One were speaking with Moses about what he is doing with the Israelites. For example (Lev 26:43): “for the abundant reason that they rejected My rules…”
ויש נמי דברים שא[מר] הקב"ה ל[מ]שה לכתב כאילו הוא עצמו אמרן לישראל, כגון "שמע ישראל וכו'" (דברים ה:א, ו:ד, ט:א), "כי יי' אלהיכם הוא אלהי האלהים וכו'" (דברים י:יז). וכגון קללות דמשנה תורה (דברים כח) כגון "יככה יי'" (כב, כז, כח, לה), "ישא יי' עליך גוי מרחוק" (מט), "יתנך יי'" (כה) [או: "והפיצך יי'" (סד)].
But there are also things that the Blessed Holy One told Moses to write as if he himself was saying them to the Israelites, such as “Hear, O Israel, etc.” (Deut 5:1, 6:4, 9:1), “for the LORD your God is the God of Gods, etc.” (Deut 10:17), and like the curses in Deuteronomy (ch. 28) such as “the LORD will strike you” (vv. 22, 27, 28, 35), “the LORD will bring upon you a faraway nation” (v. 49), “the LORD will give you” [or: “the LORD will disperse you” (v. 64)].
He writes:
וזה הוא פירוש דברי אביי, כלומ[ר] הללו בלשון רבים אמורות, אמר לו הקב"ה למשה לכתבן כאלו הוא מדבר עם ישראל, והללו בלשון יחיד אמורות. אמ[ר] לו הקב"ה למשה לכתבן כאילו הוא אמרן מפי עצמו, אבל הכל מפי הקב"ה.
And this is the explanation for the words of Abaye: “These [in Leviticus] are expressed in the [2nd person] plural,” the Blessed Holy One told Moses to write them as if He (=God) were speaking with the Israelites, “but these [in Deuteronomy] are expressed in the [2nd person] singular,” the Blessed Holy One told Moses to write them as if he (=Moses) were saying them himself. Nevertheless, all of them come from the mouth of the Blessed Holy One.
See discussion of Abravanel’s view in Avi Weiss, “The Torah Is Sanctioned by God: In the Footsteps of the Abravanel,” TheTorah (2023).
Maimonides continues with two examples:
כגון שכתב ישכבנה מקום ישגלנה, ובטחורים מקום בעפלים, וכיוצא בהן,
For instance, if he wrote yishkavenah “he will lie with her” instead of yishaglenah “he will have sex with her,” or techorim “abscesses” instead of ophalim “hemorrhoids,” or the like.
A closed paragraph refers to when the writing picks up on the same line after a large space of about 9 letters, while an open paragraph refers to when the spacing goes all the way till the end, and the writing picks up on the next line. I am oversimplifying, since certain specific details are debated. For example, for a petucha, if the previous paragraph ends close to the end of the line, Maimonides says to skip the next line entirely and start on the third line (Mishneh Torah, Ahavah, “Laws of Tefillin, Mezuzah, and Torah Scroll,” 8:1–2), since a petucha always begins a line, and a setuma always begins in the middle of a line. In contrast, R. Asher ben Yehiel (Rosh, ca. 1250–1327) says we include a large space at the beginning of the next line (Tur, YD §275), since a petucha can either be a long space at the end of the previous line or the beginning of the next. For Maimonides, of course, this would be a setuma, since it begins in the middle of a line. In addition, Tractate Soferim (Higger ed., 1:15–16) has the opposite, that a petucha never begins a line. This last tradition is not represented in any contemporary Torah scrolls, as far as I am aware.
This same rule appears in the post-Talmudic tractate, Sefer Torah:
מסכת ספר תורה א:י פתוחה שעשאה סתומה, וסתומה שעשאה פתוחה, הרי זו תגנז.
Tractate Sefer Torah 1:10 An open paragraph that was written as a closed one, or a closed paragraph written as an open one—[the text] must be buried.
The same line also appears in another post-Talmudic tractate, Soferim (1:15). While these are parallel texts, as noted above, Soferim has a different definition of petucha, while the passage in Tractate Sefer Torah has the same definition as Maimonides.
MT is quite sparing when it comes to matres lectionis, while Qumran spellings often contain multiple maters.
The text continues with two further examples from the Torah and two more from Psalms:
"[דרש] דרש" (ויקרא י:טז) חציין של תיבות.
“And he shall certainly inquire” (darosh darash; Lev 10:16) is the halfway point of words [in the Torah].
"והתגלח" (ויקרא יג:לג) דפסוקים.
“And he shall be shaven” (Lev 13:33) [is the halfway point] of verses [in the Torah].
"יכרסמנה חזיר מיער" (תהלים ל:יד) ע' ד"יער" חציין של אותיות של ספר תילים.
“The boar out of the wood ravages it” (Ps 80:14)—the ayin of יער is half the letters in the book of Psalms.
"והוא רחום" (תהלים עח:לח) דפסוקים.
“And he is merciful” (Ps 78:38) [is the halfway point] in verses.
This implies that the scribes also had an exact letter count for this book as well.
The Talmud never explains the context of R. Yoḥanan’s statement. (See Rashi ad loc.)
Thus, R. Joseph Babad (1801–1874), in his Minchat Chinukh (Nitzavim 613:1), argued that only those defective and plene spellings that change a word’s meaning or generate a halakhic midrash are essential; R. Yerachmiel Gershon Edelstein (1862–1919), in his Chiddushei Ben Aryeh, refined that distinction to apply to Torah scrolls but not to tefillin and mezuzot. Each preserves Maimonides’ language at the cost of a distinction Maimonides never makes.
I made this argument in my “The Significance of Ibn Ezra’s Position that Verses Were Added to the Torah,” TheTorah (2014).
For some modern discussions of this, see David Bigman, “I Shall Fear God Alone and Not Show Favor,” TheTorah (2014); Sam Fleischacker, “Making Sense of the Revelation at Sinai,” TheTorah (2014); Chaim (Howard) Kreisel, “Were Maimonides and Some of His Followers Orthoprax?” TheTorah (2017).
See discussion in the “Nissim of Marseilles” section in Kreisel, “Were Maimonides and Some of His Followers Orthoprax?”. The quote here comes from Nissim of Marseille, מעשה נסים [A Miraculous Work], ed. Chaim (Howard) Kreisel (Mekize Nirdamim, 2000), p. 160. The title of the book is a play on the author’s name, which, when understood as a proper noun, would mean “The Work of Nissim.”
Another such example is Maimonides depiction of God communicating with Moses, as he describes in the eighth principle, when he glosses what it means that all of the Torah comes from God:
רמב"ם פרוש משניות סנהדרין י:א הקדמה כלומר שהגיעה עליו כולה מאת ה’ הגעה שקורים אותה על דרך ההשאלה דבור, ואין יודע איכות אותה ההגעה אלא הוא עליו השלום אשר הגיעה אליו.
Maimonides, com. Mishnah, Sanhedrin 10:1 intro Meaning, that it came to [Moses] entirely from God, in the kind of transmission that may be referred metaphorically as “speech.” No one knows the nature of that transmission except the person, may peace be upon him, who received it.
This was noted by Hannanel Mack, מראשית לבראשית רבה [Mereshit (From the Beginning) to Bereshit Rabba], (Carmel, 2022), 1.41. See Philo De Opificio Mundi (On the Creation of the World) 17–2, where he discusses God’s use of mental architectural plans to create the world.
This is reminiscent of a theory I’ve heard from some proponents of the Bible codes (the ones who use equidistant letter sequencing to find predictions of the future in the Torah), that perhaps the Torah is actually a kind of computer program with a false front, and we have yet to learn what it really means.
See discussion in Marc Michaels, Sefer Tagin—Olde Face, Slab-Serifs and Semi-Ligatures. Covenantal warnings and reassurance. Re-housing the Temple within the Torah, Doctoral Dissertation (University of Cambridge, 2024). See also Grossman's forthcoming article on taggin, TheTorah (2026).
The late rabbinic/early geonic period Book of Taggin, traces the tradition all the way back to the copy of the Torah Joshua is said to have written
ספר תגין הדין ספרא תאגי דאסיק עלי הכהן מן י"ב אבנים שהקים יהושע בגלגל, ומסרו לשמואל...
Sefer Tagin This is the book of tagin that Eli the priest took down from the twelve stones that Joshua raised in Gilgal, and he passed them on to Samuel…
The text continues tracing this down the line through Rabbi Akiva to R. Judah HaNasi, author of the Mishnah.
He writes:
רמב"ם, משנה תורה, ספר אהבה "הלכות תפילין מזוזה וספר תורה" ז:ח וייזהר באותיות הגדולות, ובאותיות הקטנות, ובאותיות הנקודות, ובאותיות שצורתן משונות, כגון הפיין הלפופות, והאותיות העקומות, כמו שהעתיקו הסופרים איש מפי איש. וייזהר בתגין ובמנינם, יש אות שיש עליה תג אחד, ויש אות שעליה שבעה. וכל התגין כצורת זין הן, דקין כחוט השערה:
Mishneh Torah, Ahavah, “Laws of Tefillin, Mezuzah, and Torah Scroll 7:8 Be careful [to copy] large letters, small letters, dotted letters (puncta extraordinaria), letters whose form is unusual, such as the coiled pehs, and bent letters, exactly as scribes have copied them from person to person. And be careful with the taggin and their number. Some letters have one tag, and other letters have seven. All taggin are the form of a zayin, thin like a string of hair.
Precedent for this already exists in the earliest of halakhic compendiums, the Geonic Hilkhot Pesukot min HaGeonim:
הלכות פסוקות קצ' וספר תורה שאין בו תגין מותר לקרות בו ואין תגין פסולין אבל העושה תגין הרי זה משובח, וכל שכן שבע אותיות שצריכות שלשה שלשה תגין, ואלו הן שעטנז גץ סימן. ואם אין עושה להם תגין אין [נ]פסל[ו]ת.
Hilkhot Pesukot min HaGeonim §190 And a Torah scroll that does not have taggin, it is permitted to read from it, for [absence of] taggin does not disqualify, but one who includes taggin [in writing the scroll]—such is praiseworthy. And this goes especially for the seven letters which get three taggin a piece, which are: shin, ayin, tet, nun, zayin, gimmel, tzadi (the mneumonic is šaʿatnezgatz). But if one doesn’t make [taggin] for them, they are not disqualified.
It is listed here as Rav Natronai, but Robert Brody does not include it in his critical edition of Rav Natronai’s responsa. Notably, this same responsum (with slight differences) appears in the collection Shaarei Teshuvah, and there it is attributed to Sar Shalom Gaon. Notably, Hilkhot Pesukot distinguishes taggin from paragraph breaks, where it does imply that a variation would disqualify the scroll, exactly like Maimonides:
ופתוחות וסתומות יש להן מקומות כל אחת במקומה ואין לשנות ולעשות סתומה פתוחה ופתוחה סתומה.
As for open and closed paragraphs, they have set places, each one in its set place, and one may not change this, making a closed paragraph open, or an open paragraph closed.
The questions asked:
תשובות הרבמ"ם [בלאו] סי' קנד שאלה: ותורינו הדרתו איך יהיה עשיית התגין ואם הוא הלכה למשה מסיני או תקנת חכמים או יהיה מנהג ואם כן מאיזה זמן נתקן יורינו מורה צדק את האור כי טוב ונגילה ונשמחה.
Maimonides’ Responsa (Blau ed.) §154 Question: May his honor teach us about the use of taggin, is it a law from Moses at Sinai or instituted by the sages or a custom, and if so, in what period was it instituted? Let the righteous teacher show us the light for it is good, and we will be happy and joyous.
תשובה: התגין הוא אותות קטנות בראש האותיות והן כעין זיינין דוקא אך יש חילוק באותיות יש אות שצריכה תג אחד ויש שצריכה שתים ויש שצריכה שלש וכיוצא עד שבעה זה הוא אופן עשייתן.
Answer: The taggin are small marks at the tops of the letters, shaped precisely like [miniature] zayins. But there is a distinction among the letters: one letter requires a single tag, another two, another three, and so on up to seven. This is the manner of making them.
This is how Maimonides signed all his responsa.
See discussion in Emanuel Tov, “The Scribes of Proto-MT and Their Practices,” TheTorah (2017).
The second book in Maimonides Mishneh Torah, dealing with liturgy and personal ritual.
R. Avraham was not the only sage in this period looking to be more lenient. Rabbi Menachem HaMeiri (1249–1315), in his halakhic book on scribal matters, Kiryat Sefer, argues that it all depends on the individual difference, whether the scroll is making use of a spelling that exists in a received text or whether this is a unique change. The latter invalidates the scroll; the former does not:
מאירי קרית ספר הקדמה ...כל חסר ויתר שאין הדבר ברור בו כל כך כגון שנמצא בו מחלוקת בין ספרי התיקונין או בין המדרש למסרה אין פוסלין בהם ס"ת להדייא ומה שלא נמצא בו מחלוקת פוסלין אותה בלא שום פקפוק.
Meiri, Kiryat Sefer, intro …Any defective or plene spelling which is sufficiently unclear, for instance, when there is a discrepancy between properly produced texts, or between what we find in midrash and what we find in the masorah—we do not outright invalidate a Torah scroll for these. But when there is no discrepancy [between proper texts], we invalidate the scroll without apprehension.
At this point, Meiri extends this principle back to the issue of open and closed paragraphs, essentially coming to the same conclusion as R. Avraham:
וכן נראה בפתוחה וסתומה שבכל מה שנמצא בו מחלוקת אין פוסלין אותה להדייא ובמה שלא נמצא בו מחלוקת פוסלין אותה בלא שום פקפוק, שכל שאין בו מחלוקת אין לך בקיאות גדולה מזו.
And this seems correct also for open and closed paragraphs, that in any case where we find a discrepancy [between properly produced texts], we do not outright invalidate [a scroll], but when there is no discrepancy [between proper texts], we invalidate it without apprehension, for having no discrepancy [between proper texts] is the clearest sign that we have expertise [in this case]!
Maimonides himself, however, never makes such a distinction in his codification.
I posit this since already the Talmud itself declares that we no longer have accurate traditions on defective and plene writing; if R. Avraham is willing to go against an explicit statement in the Talmud because a tradition that was not lost yet then was in his day, he would almost certainly agree to do the same when he has Talmudic precedent to back him.