R. Moshe ben Maimon commonly known as רמב״ם and Maimonides (Adapted). Credit: Wellcome Library, London
Were Maimonides and Some of His Followers Orthoprax?
Debate over Maimonides’ orthodoxy already began in his lifetime, but for the contemporary believer, the stakes are especially high.
Published: May 28, 2017
|
Last Updated: October 28, 2026
Translation is my own from the Judeo-Arabic.
See B.T. Sanhedrin 99a; see also B.T. Menahot 30a.
See my discussion of Mosaic prophecy in “What Is Prophecy?” TheTorah.com (2015).
The second point is not stated explicitly in the eighth principle but is made explicit in the following principle, in which Maimonides maintains that nothing can be added to the Torah or deleted from it.
Maimonides deals with this point in detail in his introduction to the Commentary on the Mishnah. What is derived by the thirteen principles by which the Torah is legally expounded either belongs to rabbinic law or serves only as textual support for what is handed down by tradition.
A good summary of this philosophy is found at the beginning of Halevi’s Kuzari and in Guide of the Perplexed 1.72; 2.4.
Editor’s note: See Zev Farber’s TABS essays, “Ibn Ezra’s Secret,” TheTorah.com (2013); “Seven Torah Passages of Non-Mosaic Origin According to Ibn Ezra and Bonfils,”TheTorah.com (2014); “The Significance of Ibn Ezra’s Position that Verses were Added to the Torah,” TheTorah.com (2014).
E.g., R. Yehudah HeChasid and his son R. Moshe Zaltman, R. Shmuel Ha-Zarfati, R. Joseph Bonfils, and R. Elazar ben Mattityah. Editor’s note: For more on R. Yehudah HeChasid and his son’s belief that the Torah went through some adjustments after Moses, see Baruch Schwartz, “When Moses Placed Ephraim before Manasseh,” TheTorah.com (2017) and Zev Farber, “The Song of the Well, Psalm 136, Was Removed from the Torah,”TheTorah.com (2016).
The divine origin of the oral law was not challenged by Rabbinites, but the Karaites rejected the notion that the Oral Law was given by God to Moses and brought a number of weighty arguments in defense of their position.
Editor’s note: See discussion in Seth (Avi) Kadish, “The Illuminated Palace: An Introduction to Dogma in Jewish Thought – Part 1,” TheTorah.com (2013).
See Guide of the Perplexed 3. 28, 29, 32, 35.
A number of critics, as well as followers, interpreted him as rejecting belief in the Resurrection of the Dead. Maimonides’ response is contained in his Treatise on Resurrection, where he ostensibly upholds belief in Resurrection. I say “ostensibly” because while the treatise silenced his attackers it hardly put an end to the question regarding his true view on the subject. This treatise too can be read as containing an esoteric view.
I argue this point in more detail in the second chapter of my latest book, Judaism as Philosophy: Studies in Maimonides and the Medieval Jewish Philosophers of Provence (Academic Studies Press: Boston, 2015). In a number of places, Alvin J. Reines argued the position that according to Maimonides’ secret view, Moses was the author of the Torah. See, for example, his, “Maimonides’ Concept of Mosaic Prophecy,” HUCA 40-41 (1969-1970): 169-206, and his, Maimonides and Abrabanel on Prophecy (Cincinnati: Hebrew Union College Press, 1970). A number of scholars, I among them, soon followed in his footsteps.
Maimonides discusses the Revelation at Sinai and what exactly Israel heard in Guide2.33. I analyze this chapter in my book Prophecy: The History of an Idea in Medieval Jewish Philosophy (Kluwer; Dordricht 2001), pp. 230-235.
See Guide of the Perplexed 2.5-12. The first four chapters of Mishneh Torah, “Laws of the Foundations of the Torah” are based completely on medieval Aristotelian physics and metaphysics.
An overview of the history of the esoteric interpretation of Maimonides from medieval times to the modern period, and some of the major issues involved, can be found in Aviezer Ravitzky, “The Secrets of the Guide of the Perplexed: Between the Thirteenth and the Twentieth Centuries,” in Studies in Maimonides (ed., Isadore Twersky; Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1990), pp. 159-207
I deal with this issue extensively in my discussion of Maimonides in my book Prophecy: The History of an Idea in Medieval Jewish Philosophy, chapter three, as well as in my discussion of Judah Halevi in chapter two.
Admittedly, the hints I detected in Maimonides’ writings that allude to these positions are exceptionally subtle ones, particularly in regard to the Revelation at Sinai. This is not surprising given the religious sensitivity of this subject. Thus it is easy to dismiss them as the readings of an overly active imagination. For a summary of these hints see my discussion of the “Voice of God” in Judasim as Philosophy, pp. 342-348.
Nissim belongs to a circle of Provençal Jewish philosophers who do not view God as the immediate author of the Torah. Joseph Kaspi and Levi Gersonides hint to this view as well, though they are not nearly as explicit as Nissim. See my discussion in Judaism of Philosophy where I summarize Nissim’s thought in general (chapter 6) and discuss his stance and that of other Provencal philosophers on this issue (chapter 9).
Moreover, he points to one of the midrashim of the Sages to show that they themselves allude to this secret; see discussion in David Frankel, “Moses’ Commandments: The Secret of R. Nissim of Marseilles,” TheTorah.com (2016).
Nissim ben Moshe of Marseille, Ma`aseh Nissim, ed. Howard Kreisel (Jerusalem: Mekize Nirdamim, 2000), p. 160 (translation is my own). Note that in the quote in the Mishnah, Moses is not mentioned; rather, “The Holy One blessed be He wanted for Israel to be righteous […].”
Ibid., p. 333.
Editor’s note: For some reflections on this question, see “Meditations on Torat Emet: A Symposium,” TheTorah.com (2016).