Elijah carried away into heaven by a chariot of fire, by James Tissot, ca. 1896-1902 (adapted). Artvee
Moshe Rabbeinu Never Died: The Hidden Ending
Published: October 2, 2015
|
Last Updated: September 7, 2026
E.g. Genesis/death of Joseph; Joshua/death of Joshua; 1 Samuel/death of Saul. We know now from the study of ancient orthographic practice that the end point of a biblical book was determined by a most prosaic reason, namely the standard length of an ancient scroll (much in the way that the length of a television episode today is driven by the standard half and full-hour programming slots). Nevertheless, there was clearly an attempt to align the end of a biblical book with the death of a central figure.
Much has been written on Moses’ death by both traditional and critical scholars. One particularly important study is, Samuel Loewenstamm, “The Death of Moses,” in Studies on the Testament of Abraham (George W. E. Nickelsburg, ed.; SBLSCS 6; Missoula, MT; Scholars Press, 1976), 185-217.
The popular midrashim about the early life of Abraham, including the smashing of the idols and his escape from the fiery furnace, highlight the fact that the Torah provides virtually no information about the first 75 years of the life of the father of the Jewish people or the reason for his selection. For more on this, see James L. Kugel, The Bible as it Was(Harvard University Press, 1999), 131-148.
Midrash Tanchuma, “Lech Lecha” 9; Bereshit Rabbah,“Lech Lecha” 40.
See, for example, Marc Brettler, The Creation of History in Ancient Israel (Routledge, 1998). For an example of this type of reading, see Ely Levine’s TABS essay, “The Historical Circumstances that Inspired the Korah Narrative.”
I am indebted to my teacher, Prof. Yair Zakovich, for both this methodology and the insights contained in this essay.
For more on the parallels between Joshua and Moses, see: Elie Assis, “Divine Versus Human Leadership: Joshua’s Succession,” in Saints and Role Models in Judaism and Christianity (eds. Marcel Poorthuis and Joshua Berman; Jewish and Christian Perspectives Series 7; Leiden: Brill, 2004), 25-47. The attempt to cast post-Mosaic Jewish leaders in Moses’ mold continued in later parts of the Hebrew Bible and beyond the close of the canon. The Talmud further develops the idea of Ezra as a latter-day Moses, an image that has its seeds in the biblical books of Ezra/Nehemiah.
Elijah’s journey takes 40 days. Although this has no exact parallel in Moses’ life, it is evocative of the 40 days and nights Moses spends on Mount Sinai and, to a lesser extent, to the 40 years Moses wandered in the desert.
Elijah rolls up his mantle and strikes the water before it parts. The rolled up mantle would have resembled a staff, in imitation of Moses’ staff which he used to perform miracles in Egypt and afterwards, including hitting the rock to produce water (Exod 17:5-6) and which was presumably in his hand when he raised it over the Reed Sea (Exod 14:21, 26). Being a shepherd, Moses naturally carried a crook, which became his miracle-working instrument (Exod 4:2-4). For Elijah, a 9th century prophet/professional miracle worker, the medium of choice was a mantle; the narrative is tailored so that the mantle substitutes for the staff. We see here how a later story recasts an earlier version taking into consideration the different context.
Crossing the river, Elijah ends up in the Transjordan, where Moses concluded his earthly life.
Cf. the brief note concerning Enoch in Gen 5:24.
Malachi 3:23. The prophet envisions Elijah returning to herald the coming of the “…great and awesome Day of YHWH.” Of all prophets, Elijah could easily return to earth, since he never died.
Cf. e.g. b. Sanhedrin 98a, 118a, b. Baba Metzia 85b, 114b,Pesikta d’Rav Kahanna 11:22.
Although the Torah says clearly that Moses died, the same is true of Jacob, and yet this did not stop at least one rabbi from suggesting that he did not (b. Taanit 5b).
See, for example, Rashi ad loc. In this case, Rashi is challenging the midrashic view of Rabbi Ishmael, found in Sifrei Bemidbar, “Nasso” 32 (and quote by Rashi ad loc.) which suggests that Moses buried himself.
Since Elijah was a less significant leader than Moses, the story of his immortality would not have aroused similar concern; there did not appear to be a perceived risk he would be venerated as a demigod. Likely, this lack of fear would has allowed his story to remain part of the Bible and Jewish tradition. The story of Elijah’s immortality has remained more of a curiosity in Judaism, rather than raising fears of apostasy.