Sacrificing Bulls in the Divine Presence

Is there symbolic meaning in sacrificing bulls versus sheep? Hint: Only bulls were offered at Mount Sinai.

SBL Style

Click to copy

"Sacrificing Bulls in the Divine Presence." TheTorah.com, April 24, 2025. https://www.thetorah.com/article/sacrificing-bulls-in-the-divine-presence.

APA Style

Click to copy

"Sacrificing Bulls in the Divine Presence" (2025, April 24). TheTorah.com. https://www.thetorah.com/article/sacrificing-bulls-in-the-divine-presence

Sacrificing Bulls in the Divine Presence

Aaron lays his hand on the bull (adapted), Jan Luyken, 1703. Rijks Museum

Categories:

Vayikra

Published: April 24, 2025

|

Last Updated: September 7, 2026

  1. Leviticus then continues with various sacrifices offered for sins (chs. 4–5). These are not expressions of voluntary sentiment but requirements for atonement or purification from sin.

  2. This division into types of animals also exists in the purification offerings (חטאת), but there we often find a requirement for one type or another (see below).

  3.  Naphtali S. Meshel, The “Grammar” of Sacrifice: A Generativist Study of the Israelite Sacrificial System in the Priestly Writings (Oxford, 2014), 42.

  4. A. M. Dinçol and M. Darga, “Die Feste von Karaḥna,” Anatolica 3 (1969–1970): 100. For a study of this text, see Moshe Weinfeld, “Social and Cultic Institutions in the Priestly Source Against their Ancient Near Eastern Background,” Proceedings of the Eighth World Congress of Jewish Studies (1981): 95-129. Both the morning and evening offerings in the city of Uruk, in, included bulls and rams (ANE 342–345). Both in the Bible and in Uruk we find a tendency towards more rams than bulls. For more on the combination of an animal sacrifice with a grain offering and a wine libation, see Naphtali Meshel, “Which Sacrificial Offerings Require Libations?” TheTorah (2018).  

  5. In many cases, even when the Bible adopted rituals from elsewhere in the ancient Near East, it imbued them with different meanings, and this stands out especially in the world of sacrificial offerings, where the differences are so stark as to be almost unrecognizable as the same ritual. For specifics, see Zvi Weinberg, הקורבן על פי תורת הכוהנים והמנהגים של העמים השכנים [Sacrificial Offering in the Priestly Torah and the Practices of the Neighboring Peoples] Doctoral Dissertation (Hebrew University, 1971).

  6. Moses Maimonides, The Guide to the Perplexed: A New Translation, translation and commentary by Lenn E. Goodman and Phillip I. Lieberman (Stanford University Press, 2024), 418–419.

  7. This is, as is well known, a fundamental question in the study of worship and ritual. See an extensive discussion in Meshel, The “Grammar” of Sacrifice, especially pp. 174–197.

  8. In verse 11, the person is given option to make this a meal offering if even birds are not affordable. See also Leviticus 12:8, 14:21–31.

  9.  Thus according to the Sages in the Sifra, and for example: Anson Rainey, "Sacrifice", Encyclopedia Judaica, 2nd ed., 17.639-644

  10. Cf. וְשָׁחַט אֹתוֹ “slaughter it” by the flock animal.

  11. The translation of this phrase follows that of Everett Fox. NJPS and NRSVue understand the phrase as just the general word for “offering,” but this would make the term superfluous in context, since it would describe the identical action to dashing the blood against the sides of the altar.

  12. My reading differs from that of Don Isaac Abravanel who saw in the language differences between the offering depictions nothing more than an abbreviation:

    אברבנאל ויקרא א כי הנה באמרו בעולת הצאן 'וזרקו בני אהרן הכהנים את דמו' נכלל 'והקריבו בני אהרן את הדם', כי בידוע שאם לא יקבלוהו בכלי לא יוכלו לזרוק.
    Abravanel Lev 1 For when it says by the burnt offering of the flock: “and Aaron’s sons, the priests, shall dash the blood,” it is understood that if they don’t first catch the blood in a vessel [=the language of “bring near”] that they can’t dash it.  
  13. This is repeated also by the purification and guilt offerings later (Lev 6:18, 7:2).

  14. Jacob Milgrom, Leviticus 1-16, Anchor Bible (Doubleday, 1991), 164. See also, Arie Noordtzij, Leviticus, Bible Students' Commentary, trans. by R. Togtman (Zondervan, 1982), 39; Philip J. Budd, Leviticus, New Century Bible Company (Eerdmans, 1996), 51; Anson Rainey, “Sacrifice,” Encyclopedia Judaica, 2nd ed. (1971), 17.639.

  15.  In contrast, Yoel Elitzur (מקום בפרשה: גיאוגרפיה ומשמעות במקרא [Places in the Parasha: Geography and Meaning in the Bible] [Yediot Books, 2014], 173–176) suggested that the choice of the north was a hidden polemic against the Ugaritic/Canaanite belief that the gods live on Har Tzafon (literally “Mount North”). Indeed, “north” is a term associated with gods in the Canaanite Pantheon: El-Tzafon, Baʿal-Tzafon, Anat-Tzafon, etc. Slaughtering animals in the north is an announcement that God dwells in the Tabernacle among the Israelites and not on Mount Tzafon.

  16. According to R. David Zvi Hoffmann, the passage about the burnt offering from the flocks refers essentially to the sheep that are brought as the daily offering, every morning and evening:

    הופמן ויקרא עמ' צז אולי לא רחוק להניח, שהפסוקים בויקרא א', יא-יג, שבהם מתוארת דרך הקרבתה של עולת הצאן, נאמרו כבר בהר סיני סמוך אחרי ההוראה על דבר עולת התמיד.
    Hoffmann Lev p. 97 Perhaps it is not too much to assume that the verses—Leviticus 1:11–13—in which the procedure of sacrificing a burnt offering is depicted, was commanded already at Mount Sinai, around the time of the command about the daily offering [=Exod 29:38–42].

    For more on Hoffmann’s understanding of how the revelation of sacrificial law unfolded, see Zev Farber, “‘This Is the Torah’ for the Priests Performing the Offerings,” TheTorah (2017). In the end, even Hoffmann admits that the laws of the burnt offering laid out in Leviticus 1 apply to any burnt offering from flock animals that an Israelite brings voluntarily, only that the verses are primarily addressing the public daily offering in the context in which they were revealed.

  17. The same exact procedure is to take place for the sin-offering of the entire congregation (Lev 4:16–18).

  18. The same is true for the sin offering of the average Israelite.

  19. The one exception that requires explanation, in light of what we’ve seen above, is the billy goat purification-offering of the people that is brought into the Tent of Meeting on the Day of Atonement (Lev 16:15–16), since it is a flock animal, not cattle. Perhaps this offering parallels the billy goat sent out to Azazel in the wilderness, and the animals need to be identical. Nevertheless, it seems more likely that the choice of animal here is connected to the process of cleansing the Tabernacle. Though an attempt to tease this out requires a detailed treatment, the key point is in the verse about how this offering cleanses the altar:

    ויקרא טז:יח וְיָצָא אֶל הַמִּזְבֵּחַ אֲשֶׁר לִפְנֵי יְ־הוָה וְכִפֶּר עָלָיו וְלָקַח מִדַּם הַפָּר וּמִדַּם הַשָּׂעִיר וְנָתַן עַל קַרְנוֹת הַמִּזְבֵּחַ סָבִיב.
    Lev 16:18 He shall go out to the altar that is before YHWH and purge it: he shall take some of the blood of the bull and of the goat and apply it to each of the horns of the altar.

    While the Sages understand this as a reference to the golden incense altar inside the Tabernacle, the simple meaning is that is cleansing the main altar in the courtyard, which, as noted, is symbolically connected to flock animals. In any event, the Yom Kippur cleansing ritual has an unusual mix of rituals inside and outside the sacred precinct. Finally, the bringing of the billy-goat inside the Tent of Meeting may also be connected to the mixing of the blood of this offering with that of the bull of the high priest’s purification-offering.

  20. R. Avraham ibn Ezra seems to have understood the word “bulls” here to apply only to the offering of wellbeing and not the burnt offering:

    אבן עזרא שמות כד:ה והזכיר עם השלמים פרים, כי האוכלים רבים היו.
    Ibn Ezra Exod 24:5 With the wellbeing offering it mentions bulls since many people would be consuming it.

    In contrast, R. Moses Nahmanides understood the term bulls to be referring to the burnt offerings as well:

    רמב"ן כד:ה והנה העלו העולות וזבחו השלמים כולם פרים, כטעם פר כהן משיח, ופר העלם דבר, ופר עבודה זרה, גם פרה אדומה כן.
    Ramban 24:5 And they brought burnt offerings and sacrificed wellbeing offerings, all of which were bulls, for the same reason as the bull [=sin offering] of the anointed priest and the bull of the unknown sin, and the bull of the sin of idolatry. And the red heifer as well.
  21. The standard understanding is that the second daily burnt offering closes out the sacrificial day, since offerings aren’t made at night, though it seems to me that it is better understood as beginning the process of consuming sacrificial meet, which takes place at night. See Jonathan Grossman, תורת הקרבנות: מחוות של בשר ורוח [The Sacrificial Service: Gestures of Flesh and Spirit] (Maggid, 2021), 416–417.

  22. Notably, the next verse uses the phrase “entrance to the Tent of Meeting” that is used consistently for bull offerings:

    שמות כט:מב עֹלַת תָּמִיד לְדֹרֹתֵיכֶם פֶּתַח אֹהֶל מוֹעֵד לִפְנֵי יְ־הוָה אֲשֶׁר אִוָּעֵד לָכֶם שָׁמָּה לְדַבֵּר אֵלֶיךָ שָׁם.
    Exod 29:42 A regular burnt offering throughout the generations, at the entrance of the Tent of Meeting before YHWH. For there I will meet with you, and there I will speak with you.

    In truth, the outer altar is often referred to as “the altar at the entrance to the Tent of Meeting.” My main point above is to point out the change in writing between the slaughter of cattle and the slaughter of flock animals.

  23. Its symbolic import is especially strong in Ugarit, where the central deity El was envisioned as a bull, and other gods and goddesses, such as Baal, Anat, and others, were described in language connected with bulls. See Adrian Curtis and Adam S. van der Woude, “Some Observations on 'Bull' Terminology in the Ugaritic Texts and in the Old Testament,” in In Quest of the Part: Studies on Israelite Religion, Literature and Prophetism, ed., Adrian Curtis and Adam S. van der Woude, Oudtestamentische Studien (Brill 1990). It is worth noting that many have understood the story of the Golden Calf in the context of fertility rituals, especially because of the phrase וַיָּקֻמוּ לְצַחֵק “and they got up to play” (Exod 32:6). Others have argued that due to the warlike associations of bulls in ancient Near Eastern religious imagery, that this would be the better context ** previous phrase is unclear** , namely, that the Israelites wanted an image of a fighting deity to protect them against their enemies. See discussion in, John G. Janzen, “The Character of the Calf and Its Cult in Exodus 32,” Catholic Bible Quarterly 52 (1990): 597–607.

  24. See Menahem Haran, “המשכן: הדירוג הטכני–החמרי” [The Tabernacle: Its Technical-Material Gradation], in מקרא ועולמו: מבחר מחקרים ספרותיים והיסטוריים [The Bible and Its World: Selected Biblical and Historical Studies] (Magnes 2009), 50–61; repr. from ספר טור-סיני: מאמרים בחקר התנ"ך מוגש לכבוד הפרופ' נ.ה. טור-סיני למלאת לו שבעים שנה [The Book of Tur-Sinai: Articles on the Study of the Bible Presented in Honor of Professor N. H. Tur-Sinai Upon His Turning Seventy] (Kiryat Sefer, 1960), 27–42. See also, idem, Temple and Temple Service in Ancient Israel (Eisenbrauns, 1985), 158–165 (“The Material Gradation”).