An illustration from a hebrew copy of Maimonides’ Guide of the Perplexed made by Ferrer Bassa in 1348 in Barcelona. Maimonides teaches about the ‘measure of men’. zeevveez / flickr
The Mitzvah to Love God: Shadal’s Polemic against the Philosophical Interpretation
Philosophically inclined rabbis, such as Maimonides, attempted to understand the mitzvah to love God in Aristotelian terms, imagining God as a non-anthropomorphic abstract being. Shadal argues that this elitist approach twists both Torah and philosophy, and in its place, he offers a moralistic approach that can be achieved by all.
Published: August 16, 2016
|
Last Updated: September 7, 2026
[1] His treatment of the Torah differs from that of the rest of Tanakh. He was willing to emend the vowels in the Torah but even the consonants in Nakh.
[2] See Shmuel Vargon S. D. Luzzatto: Moderate Criticism in Biblical Exegesis (Ramat Gan: Bar Ilan University, 2013) [Heb.].
At a relatively young age he published a book, Vikkuach al ha-Kabbala, to prove that the Zohar could not have been written in Talmudic times and must be a medieval work.
For more details on Shadal, see my TABS essay, “Peshat vs. Halakha Dilemma: Shadal and Tradition,” and the literature cited there.
[5] The JPS Torah Commentary: Deuteronomy (Philadelphia: JPS, 1996), p. 77.
Shadal lived well before the discovery of the Dead Sea Scrolls. His understanding of the Essenes as a group of Jews who secluded themselves from society at large presumably comes from his knowledge of the works of Philo of Alexandria and Josephus.
This is not the only time in his Torah commentary that he does so. See, for example his commentary to Exodus 21:10.
For an understanding of Rambam’s interpretation of the Maaseh Merkava (the secret of the chariot) as being purely a scientific secret, dealing with stars and planets, see Daniel Davies’ TABS essay, “The Secret of the Maaseh Merkava According to Maimonides.”