What Is Prophecy?

The nature of prophecy is perhaps one of the most overlooked questions, but it was critically important to the medieval Jewish philosophers Sa’adia Gaon, Judah Halevi, Ibn Ezra, and Maimonides.

SBL Style

Click to copy

"What Is Prophecy?." TheTorah.com, September 10, 2015. https://www.thetorah.com/article/what-is-prophecy.

APA Style

Click to copy

"What Is Prophecy?" (2015, September 10). TheTorah.com. https://www.thetorah.com/article/what-is-prophecy

What Is Prophecy?

Moses receives the tablets, Pieter Franciscus Martenasie, after Charles Joseph Dominique Eisen, 1739-1789 (adapted). Rijksmuseum

Categories:

Beha’alotcha

Published: September 10, 2015

|

Last Updated: September 7, 2026

  1. Nahum Glatzer, Franz Rosenzweig: His Life and Thought, p. 242. Rosenzweig’s letter was addressed to four of the members of the Lehrhaus – a society of adult Jewish education founded in Frankfurt, Germany, including Glatzer himself.

  2. Unlike the humanlike description of angels in the biblical text, in Saadia these angels are made of a pure luminous matter.

  3. R. Saadiah is convinced by the rational arguments advanced by the Islamic theologians and based on Greek philosophical notions that God is the absolute incorporeal One. Since reason in his view demonstrates this notion and there can be no contradictions between revelation and demonstrative reason, the corporeal descriptions of God in the Bible must be interpreted metaphorically.

  4. Moses, as opposed to the other prophets, was allowed to see the Glory up close, though only its back which is less luminous than its front and which causes a person to disintegrate due to its power. See Book of Belief and Opinions 2. 12.

  5. Halevi further argues that the miraculous writing on the tablets served as proof of God’s miraculous verbal revelation: “Accompanying the divine speech was the divine writing. God engraved these Ten Commandments on two tablets of precious stone, and gave them to Moses. They saw the divine writing, just as they heard the divine speech.”

  6. Nevertheless, Ibn Ezra does admit that sometimes when the Torah references an angel communicating a message, it actually means another prophet (מלאך does mean “messenger”). In such cases, the prophet on the receiving end is awake and not dreaming.

  7. Ibn Ezra does not say this outright, but he hints as much in his gloss on Gen 18:13, which references his comments on Exodus (short commentary on Exod 3:7 and 3:13), where he deals with angels, describing them as non-material beings or the souls of planets (see also his long commentary on Exod 3:15). In line with the previous note, however, Ibn Ezra does cite the possibility advocated by others that the angels/messengers were other prophets (Gen 18:13).

    ומפרשים אחרים אמרו, כי אלו ג’ אנשים נביאים היו

  8. וכל הנביאי’ לבד ממשה אחר עבור כבוד השם על פניו נבואתם כולם במראות הם גם בחלום על כן אמרתי על אברהם אבינו בנבואה על נסיון האלהים ולקח המאכלת ואזנו נוטה לשמוע מהרה
  9. ונשמת האדם ממינם, ומקבלת כח עליון כפי מערכת המשרתים, וכל המשרת כנגד הצבא הגדול בעת הבראו. ואם תחכם הנשמה תעמוד בסוד המלאכים ותוכל לקבל כח גדול מכח עליון שקבל על ידי אור המלאכים. אז יהיה דבק בשם הנכבד,
  10. וזהו שנדר יעקב והיה ד’ לי לאלהים (ברא’ כח, כא), כי יתבודד כל ימי חיין לדבקה בשם כפי כחו… ובני הנביאים היו מתבודדים, אולי יקבלו כל אחד כפי כחו.
  11. Maimonides mentions the need for this state to attain prophecy in his “Laws of the Principles of the Torah” (7:4).

  12.  וי”א כי הנבואה נסתלקה משניהם בעבור אבלם, ועדותם דבר אלישע

  13. Maimonides makes the same point in his Guide of the Perplexed (2.36).

  14. וחשב להוליך אשתו ובניו למצרים, ושיצאו יחדיו עם ישראל. ולא היתה עצה נכונה, כי הוא בא להוציא ישראל, והם יראו שבא עם אשתו ועם בניו לגור שם. ואל תתמה, איך יחשוב נביא בדברי העולם דבר שאיננו נכון, כי הנה מצאנו דוד (ש”ב ז, ב – ג) ששאל אל נתן הנביא היש ישר לבנות בית לשם, והוא השיב כל אשר בלבבך עשה וד’ עמך. ובלילה נאמר לו בנבואה שיאמר אל דוד שהוא לא יבנה הבית.
  15. הנביאים יתחלקו לב’ חלקים. החלק הא’ שליח במצות, והחלק השני נביאי העתיד, ואם יצטרכו לאמר דבר שאיננו כהוגן לא יזיק, רק השליח לא יתכן שיכזב כלל. גם הנה דוד נכתב עליו איש האלהים (דה”ב ח, יד) ואמר רוח ד’ דבר בי (ש”ב כג, ב) בלבל דבריו עם אחימלך ואמר ויהיו כלי הנערים קדש (ש”א כא, ו) לצורך שעה. גם אלישע, שאמר לחזאל לך אמור לו חיה תחיה (מ”ב ח, י), אף על פי שפירושו חיה תחיה מחולי זה, הראני השם כי יהרג, וכן מיכיהו אמר תפלת שוא עלה והצלח (מ”א כב, טו) דרך מוסר. וכן אמר דניאל מרי חלמא לשנאך (דניאל ד, טז), ולהיותו כנגד השם דרך דרש, וכן אמר אברהם וגם אמנה (ברא’ כ, יב), ונשתחוה ונשובה (ברא’ כב, ה).
  16. This view, which appears to be rooted in the writings of the great Muslim philosopher Ibn Sina (circa 980-1037), subsequently influenced many other Jewish philosophers.

  17. In his subsequent long commentary on Exodus 3.15 and Exodus 6.3, Ibn Ezra elaborates upon this idea. He divides all that exists into three worlds, the highest one consisting of the incorporeal existents, the angels and the middle one consists of the heavenly bodies that influence earthly matter. While human beings belong to the third and lowest world, the soul is treated as above the middle world, thereby close to the world of incorporeal existents. Note however that in his long commentary on Exodus 19.20 Ibn Ezra appears to waver on this issue and traces the origin of the soul to the middle world.

  18. In a similar vein, Ibn Ezra often seeks out naturalistic reasons for explaining the purpose of many of the commandments. Some of them, such as sacrifices, he sees as having special natural properties that help in divination. The hoshen mishpat of the high priest is treated by him as an astrolabe, while many of its stones also are conducive to help the imagination to attain knowledge of the future. (See Yoel’s TABS essay, “The Urim VeTumim.”) Astrological considerations pay a part in many of Ibn Ezra’s discussion of the divine commandments.

  19. For more on this, see Zev Farber’s TABS essays, “Ibn Ezra’s Secret: Late Editorial Comments in the Opening Chapters of Deuteronomy,”  “The Significance of Ibn Ezra’s Position that Verses were Added to the Torah,” and “Seven Non-Mosaic Passages in the Torah according to Ibn Ezra and R. Joseph Bonfils.”

  20. For Maimonides, this would not only be considered radical but heretical (see his 8thprinciple). For Maimonides nothing less was at stake than the very integrity of the Torah, and by extension the immutability of all its parts.

  21. For more on this Ibn Ezra, including Nahmanides’ critique, see Martin Lockshin’s, “The Existence of Two Versions of the Decalogue: The Approaches of Chazal and the Pashtanim.” TheTorah.com (2015), and "Two Versions of the Decalogue: Ibn Ezra’s Non-Explanation" TheTorah.com (2019)

  22. Ibn Ezra’s earliest supercommentators, most of them who lived in Provence, were clearly aware of this point and hence saw in him a kindred spirit of Maimonides, if not actually influencing the views and interpretations of the Great Eagle. Indeed we may infer from many of Ibn Ezra’s remarks that he is representative of a prevailing trend in Andalusian Jewish thought that characterizes other thinkers as well, many whose works are lost to us.

  23. For an alternative interpretation of Maimonides’ 8th principle of faith, see Sam Fleischacker’s TABS essay, “Making Sense of the Revelation at Sinai: Revisiting Maimonides’ Eighth Principle of Faith.”

  24. Some of Maimonides’ followers in Provence adopted in their own thought a radical naturalistic approach, viewing Moses as the author of the Torah as a result of his prophetic attainment. R. Nissim of Marseilles presents this approach almost explicitly. This story however I will reserve for a future occasion.