When Did Jews Start Observing Torah?

By the 1st century C.E., observance of Torah laws is abundantly evident in Judean society. But how far back does this widespread observance go?

SBL Style

Click to copy

"When Did Jews Start Observing Torah?." TheTorah.com, October 14, 2022. https://www.thetorah.com/article/when-did-jews-start-observing-torah.

APA Style

Click to copy

"When Did Jews Start Observing Torah?" (2022, October 14). TheTorah.com. https://www.thetorah.com/article/when-did-jews-start-observing-torah

When Did Jews Start Observing Torah?

123rf, adapted

Published: October 14, 2022

|

Last Updated: September 7, 2026

  1. The question of when the Jewish People first came to know and observe the laws of the Torah lies at the center of my new book, The Origins of Judaism: An Archaeological-Historical Reappraisal, The Anchor Yale Bible Reference Library (New Haven, CN: Yale University Press, 2022).

  2. The “Sabbath” is mentioned several times outside of the Pentateuch, but most of these texts (2 Kgs 4:23; 11:5, 7, 9; 16:18; Isa 1:13; 66:23; Ezek 44:24; 45:17; 46:1, 3–4, 12; Hos 2:13; Ps 92:1; Lam 2:6; Neh 9:14; 10:34; 1 Chr 9:32; 23:31; 2 Chr 2:3; 8:13; 23:4, 8; 31:3) do not seem to know anything at all of a notion that certain activities are prohibited on the Sabbath. And outside of the Pentateuch and Ezek 46:1, no biblical texts relate the Sabbath to a “seventh day” or as otherwise occurring on any kind of weekly basis. Because of this, several scholars have suggested that for these biblical writers, the Sabbath was regarded as an essentially cultic institution, characterized by its own special sacrificial rites, and observed on a monthly (rather than weekly) basis (i.e., as a full-moon festival); see, e.g., Johannes Meinhold, “Die Entstehung des Sabbats,” Zeitschrift für die Alttestamentliche Wissenschaft 29 (1909): 81–112; Gnana Robinson, The Origin and Development of the Old Testament Sabbath: A Comprehensive Exegetical Approach (Frankfurt am Main: Lang, 1988); Alexandra Grund, Die Entstehung des Sabbats: Seine Bedeutung für Israels Zeitkonzept und Erinnerungskultur (Tübingen: Mohr Siebeck, 2011). Editor’s note: See also, Jacob L. Wright, “Shabbat of the Full Moon,” TheTorah (2015); idem, “How and When the Seventh Day Became Shabbat,” TheTorah (2015).  Amos 8:5 tells of unscrupulous wheat vendors who would wait for the day of “the (new) month” and “the Sabbath” to pass before selling their grain, but this does not necessarily imply that it was regarded as prohibited to engage in commerce on the Sabbath (or on the new moon for that matter); it may only assume that many people were involved with these festivals, and as a result, these days did not function as normal times for business (see Robinson, The Origin and Development of the Old Testament Sabbath, 53–57). The three passages outside the Pentateuch that refer explicitly to Sabbath prohibitions (Jer 17:19–27; Neh 10:32; 13:15–22) are all presented against a backdrop where the general populace is in fact said not to be observing these prohibitions.

  3. Although preceded by others, Julius Wellhausen was probably the most influential proponent of the idea that the promulgation of the Mosaic law in the postexilic period marks the endpoint of “ancient Israel” (altes Israel) and the starting point of “Judaism” (Judentum); see his Prolegomena to the History of Israel (Edinburgh: Black, 1885), esp. 1–13.

  4. Editor’s Note: For some discussions of this text, see Jacob L. Wright, “The Origins of Torah Study,” TheTorah (2015); Lisbeth S. Fried, “Sukkot in Ezra-Nehemiah and the Date of the Torah,” TheTorah (2015); Aaron Demsky, “Historical Hakhel Ceremonies and the Origin of Public Torah Reading,” TheTorah (2017).

  5. See, e.g., Wellhausen, Prolegomena to the History of Israel, 405–410. Editor’s note: For a survey of this period and where the various events relevant to the Judeans fit in, see Zev Farber, “The 220-Year History of the Achaemenid Persian Empire,” TheTorah (2017).

  6. Contra Wellhausen’s startling claim regarding Neh 8: “The credibility of the narrative appears on the face of it” (Prolegomena to the History of Israel, 408 n. 1). For a notable appraisal of all these stories as fictional, see Charles C. Torrey, Ezra Studies (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1910). For a recent survey of scholarship on the historicity of the Ezra- Nehemiah narratives, see Philip Y. Yoo, Ezra and the Second Wilderness (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2017), 10–12.

  7. “Terminus ante quem” is a technical term used widely by archaeologists but not always well understood by non-specialists. When excavating a site, it is only seldom possible to date a particular layer of excavated material to a precise moment in time. A good example of a well-dated archaeological context is a destruction layer in Jerusalem that contains first-century C.E. pottery together with coins dating to the fifth year of the Great Revolt, a stratum that may be confidently dated to the summer of 70 C.E. A layer that lies directly above this stratum may be said to date to the year 70 C.E. or later, while a layer which lies directly below this stratum may be said to date to the year 70 C.E. or earlier. In technical jargon, the year 70 C.E. is the terminus post quem for the upper layer and the terminus ante quem for the lower layer. If no other evidence is available to help date these layers, this will be the most we will be able to say about their dating. In a similar way, the date of the earliest available evidence demonstrating that Judeans knew of something resembling the Torah and were observing its laws will serve as the terminus ante quem for the earliest emergence of Judaism. That is to say, Judaism must have first emerged at this time or earlier. Lacking further evidence, this is the most we can determine with any degree of confidence.

  8. E.g., Philo, Embassy 361–363; Flaccus 95–96; Acts 10:11–11:18; Josephus, War 2:152; Ag. Apion 2:234–235; Plutarch, Quaest. conv. 4.4:4–5:3; Tacitus, Hist. 5.4:1; Juvenal, Sat. 6:160; 14:98–99. For more on Roman authors writing about ancient Judeans’ eschewal of pork, see Malka Z. Simkovich, “Why Rome Is Likened to a Boar,” TheTorah (2019).

  9. E.g., Matt 15:1–20; 23:25–28; Mark 7:1–23; Luke 11:37–41, 44; John 2:6; 3:25; 11:55; 18:28; Josephus, War 5:226–227 ; Ant. 18:37–38; Ag. Ap. 2:103–104, 198. For an accessible overview of the archaeological finds, see my “Jewish Purity Practices in Roman Judea: The Evidence of Archaeology,” The Ancient Near East Today 5/2 (2017).

  10. See Lee. I. Levine, “Figural Art in Ancient Judaism,” Ars Judaica 1 (2005): 9–26.

  11. For an overview of the finds, see my “The Distribution of Tefillin Finds among the Judean Desert Caves,” in The Caves of Qumran: Proceedings of the International Conference, Lugano 2014, ed. Marcello Fidanzio (Leiden: Brill, 2016), 161–173.

  12. Sabbath prohibitions: Philo, Embassy 158; Matt 28:1; Mark 15:42–16:1; Luke 23:50–56; Josephus, Ag. Ap. 2:282; Apion, Aegypt. (in Josephus, Ag. Ap. 2:21); Seneca the Younger, De Superst. (in Augustine, Civ. 6:11); Frontinus, Strat. 2.1:17; Tacitus, Hist. 5.4:3–4.; Passover: Philo, Spec. Laws 2:145; Matt 26:17–30; Mark 14:12–26; Luke 22:7–19; Josephus, War 6:422–428; Ant. 3:320–321; Yom Kippur: Philo, Spec. Laws 1:186; Josephus, War 5:236; Strabo, Geogr. 16.2:40 (also probably cited by Josephus in Ant. 14:66–68); Pompeius Trogus, Hist. Phil. 36 (in Justin, Epit. 2:14); Plutarch, Quaest. conv. 4.6:2; Tacitus, Hist. 5.4:3; Suetonius, Aug. 76:2 (in a purported quotation from Augustus to Tiberius); Sukkot: Philo, Flaccus 116–117; Josephus, War 6:301; Josephus, Ant. 13:372; Plutarch, Quaest. conv. 4.6:2.

  13. Yaakov Meshorer, A Treasury of Jewish Coins: From the Persian Period to Bar Kokhba (Jerusalem: Yad Ben-Zvi, 2001), 125–126 (nos. 211–214).

  14. Josephus, Ant. 14.226 ff; 16.163, 168.

  15. Plutarch, Vita Ciceronis 7:6.

  16. For more on the emergence of the practice of ritual immersion and the first appearance of ritual immersion pools, see my, “On the Origins of Tevilah (Ritual Immersion),” TheTorah (2017).

  17. Meshorer, A Treasury of Jewish Coins, groups A–V.

  18. Recent zooarchaeological studies on pork consumption in the Southern Levant have indicated a highly complex picture of when and where pigs were and were not being raised and eaten; see especially Lidar Sapir-Hen, Guy Bar-Oz, Yuval Gadot, and Israel Finkelstein, “Pig Husbandry in Iron Age Israel and Judah New Insights Regarding the Origin of the ‘Taboo,’” Zeitschrift des Deutschen Palästina-Vereins 129 (2013): 1–20; Lidar Sapir-Hen, “Food, Pork Consumption, and Identity in Ancient Israel,” Near Eastern Archaeology 82 (2019): 52–59. Nothing in these data maps neatly onto any supposed Israelite or Judahite taboo against eating pork; contra Avraham Faust, “Pigs in Space (and Time): Pork Consumption and Identity Negotiations in the Late Bronze and Iron Ages of Ancient Israel,” Near Eastern Archaeology 81 (2018): 276–299.

  19. Yonatan Adler and Omri Lernau, “The Pentateuchal Dietary Proscription against Finless and Scaleless Aquatic Species in Light of Ancient Fish Remains,” Tel Aviv 48 (2021): 5–26. For more on what we can learn from zooarchaeological remains of fish, see Omri Lernau, “What Kinds of Fish Were Eaten in Ancient Jerusalem?” TheTorah (2019).

  20. Meshorer, A Treasury of Jewish Coins, nos. 1–26.

  21. For a recent treatment of the ritual and cultic practices of Judeans at Elephantine, see Gard Granerød, Dimensions of Yahwism in the Persian Period: Studies in the Religion and Society of the Judaean Community at Elephantine (Berlin: de Gruyter, 2016). For the material from Babylonia, see Tero Alstola, Judeans in Babylonia: A Study of Deportees in the Sixth and Fifth Centuries BCE (Leiden: Brill, 2020).

  22. Ilaria Bultrighini and Sacha Stern, “The Seven-Day Week in the Roman Empire,” in Calendars in the Making: The Origins of Calendars from the Roman Empire to the Later Middle Ages, ed. Sacha Stern, Time, Astronomy, and Calendars 10 (Leiden: Brill, 2021), 10–79 [11–17].

  23. Hans Julius Wolff, “Law in Ptolemaic Egypt,” in Essays in Honor of C. Bradford Welles (New Haven: American Society of Papyrologists, 1966), 67–77.

  24. The idea was first suggested by Michael LeFebvre in: Collections, Codes, and Torah: The Re-characterization of Israel’s Written Law (New York: T&T Clark, 2006), 146–182.

  25. Reinhard G. Kratz, Historical and Biblical Israel: The History, Tradition, and Archives of Israel and Judah, translated by Paul M. Kurtz (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2015), 185–186; John J. Collins, The Invention of Judaism: Torah and Jewish Identity from Deuteronomy to Paul (Oakland: University of California Press, 2017), 184–185. Famously, the authors of 1 and 2 Maccabees portrayed the actions of Antiochus IV, which led to the Hasmonean uprising, as decrees against Torah observance. It is quite possible, however, that the actual Seleucid persecutions had nothing at all to do with Torah, but rather were aimed against the traditional cult in the Jerusalem temple and perhaps also against other aspects of traditional Judean culture. It was only at a later date that the authors of these works retroactively and anachronistically sought to portray these persecutions against the traditional Judean cult and culture as persecutions against the laws of the Torah. In this way, the leaders of the Hasmonean revolt could be portrayed as saviors and restorers of the Torah rather than as promulgators of a newly adopted system of law.