David feigning madness before Achish (adapted), Cassell's Illustrated Family Bible, 1860
Chaos Crowned: King David’s Troubling Rise to the Throne
After Saul’s failed reign, David might seem like Israel’s salvation. Yet the biblical narrative offers a subtle but pointed critique—signaling that David’s impending rule will be no better than Saul’s.
Published: August 26, 2025
|
Last Updated: October 28, 2026
Biblical translations follow NJPS, with modifications.
On the critique of Saul’s kingship, see my article “King Saul’s Downfall: Sight and Sound,” TheTorah (2024).
The literary analysis here focuses on the final redacted Masoretic text of the account of David’s early career (1 Samuel 16:14–2 Samuel 5), a complex of material conventionally known as “the history of David’s rise.” Leonhard Rost (1896–1979) was the first scholar to argue that this unit contains a unified narrative. See Leonhard Rost, Die Überlieferung von der Thronnachfolge Davids [The Succession to the Throne of David], BWANT III 6 (Stuttgart: W. Kohlhammer, 1926). Artur Weiser (1893–1978) later argued that the narrative’s main purpose is to legitimate David’s succession to the throne by, for example, connecting David to the royal family through marriage, presenting David as worthy of kingship, and explaining away questionable aspects of his career. See Artur Weiser, “Die Legitimation des Königs David: Zur Eigenart und Entstehung der sogen. Geschichte von Davids Aufstieg” [The Legitimation of King David: On the Characteristics and Origin of the So-Called History of David's Rise], VT 16 (1966): 325–354. Scholarly opinions regarding the composition of the unit differ. Some view it as a heterogeneous collection of materials shaped by a later author into a unified narrative. Others argue that it includes a largely unified original narrative to which secondary material has been added. See P. Kyle McCarter, 1 Samuel: A New Translation with Introduction and Commentary (New York: Doubleday, 1980), 27–28; and P. Kyle McCarter, Jr., “The Apology of David,” in Reconsidering Israel and Judah: Recent Studies on the Deuteronomistic History, ed. Gary N. Knoppers and J. Gordon McConville, Sources for Biblical and Theological Study 8 (Winona Lake, IN: Eisenbrauns, 2000), 260–275. McCarter himself holds to the latter view. More recently, scholars have suggested that the narrative’s main purpose is to connect originally independent accounts about Saul and David. Jacob Wright, for example, in David, King of Israel, and Caleb in Biblical Memory (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2014), 35–37, argues that the unit contains an original narrative about David’s rise to power—as a warlord who consolidates rule over Judah—that was subsequently expanded and extensively edited to connect David with Saul and with Israel. See also several of the studies in the anthology David in the Desert: Tradition and Redaction in the “History of David’s Rise,” ed. Hannes Bezzel and Reinhard G. Kratz (Berlin: de Gruyter, 2021).
My interest here is the critique of monarchy within the literary depiction of David, and thus I do not focus on the “historical David.” Numerous studies, however, have concluded that the narratives do not present David as a man of high moral character. See, e.g., Steven Mckenzie, King David: A Biography (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2000), who notes that anthropologists have likened David’s rise to those of “Middle Eastern despots” (p. 22). See also Baruch Halpern, David’s Secret Demons: Messiah, Murderer, Traitor, King (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2001); and Joel Baden, The Historical David: The Real Life of an Invented Hero (New York: HarperCollins, 2013). Even those who view the history of David’s rise as a vindication of his qualifications for the throne see glimpses here and there of the corruption that is to come while on the throne. For a good example of one episode, sandwiched among others, that reveals the David we will come to know in the Bathsheba scandal, see J. D. Levenson, “1 Samuel 25 as Literature and History,” CBQ 40 (1978): 11–28.
Editor’s note: See Nehama Aschkenasy, “Michal’s Unrequited Love for David,” TheTorah (2024).
By contrast, in what may be Saul’s most lucid moment, he commits suicide rather than allow himself to be taken captive by the Philistines and suffer humiliating abuse at their hand (1 Sam 31:4).
Robert Polzin’s comment on this episode applies equally throughout the life of David: “However successfully David is shown escaping the clutches of Saul, he cannot escape the scrutiny of the reader. The story of David’s rise to power is contrived as much against him as for him.” See Robert Polzin, Samuel and the Deuteronomist: A Literary Study of the Deuteronomic History, Part Two; 1 Samuel (Bloomington, IN: Indiana University Press, 1989), 217. Halpern, David’s Secret Demons, 287–294, argues, based on a combination of incisive literary analysis and archeological evidence: “All signs thus point to a long and sincere Davidic commitment to the Philistines of Gath.”
McCarter notes: “Such groups, representing a chronic annoyance or threat to established authorities, lived on the fringes of society throughout the Middle and Late Bronze Ages.” See P. Kyle McCarter, “The Historical David,” Interpretation 40 (1986): 117–129 at pp. 121–122.
Although the term משפט has a wide range of meanings in the OT, its predominant sense is legal, as Baruch Halpern has shown in his The Constitution of the Monarchy (Chico, CA: Scholars Press, 1981), 224–225.
Moreover, David is acting as a sovereign, but he lacks any constituency over which he can assert his sovereignty, and he is depopulating the territory over which he could potentially have ruled.
Editor’s note: On herem laws, see Mordechai Cogan, “Deuteronomy’s Herem Law: Protecting Israel at the Cost of its Humanity,” TheTorah (2022); and Hacham Isaac S. D. Sassoon, “Obliterating Cherem,” TheTorah (2015).
My reading here is consistent with a guarded suspicion regarding David’s motives and actions. See for instance David Jobling’s analysis of chapter 27 in his Berit Olam: Studies in Hebrew Narrative and Poetry—1 Samuel (Collegeville, MN: Liturgical Press, 1998), 234–241, which argues: “The text works to repress a story in which David intends, at least from 27:1, to switch his allegiance permanently to the Philistines” (at p. 234). The reference to 27:1 is the linchpin of Jobling’s argument. It presents David’s internal monologue which discloses David’s genuine intentions:
שׁמואל א כז:א וַיֹּאמֶר דָּוִד אֶל לִבּוֹ עַתָּה אֶסָּפֶה יוֹם אֶחָד בְּיַד שָׁאוּל אֵין לִי טוֹב כִּי הִמָּלֵט אִמָּלֵט אֶל אֶרֶץ פְּלִשְׁתִּים וְנוֹאַשׁ מִמֶּנִּי שָׁאוּל לְבַקְשֵׁנִי עוֹד בְּכָל גְּבוּל יִשְׂרָאֵל וְנִמְלַטְתִּי מִיָּדוֹ.
1 Sam 27:1 David said to himself, “Some day I shall certainly perish at the hands of Saul. The best thing for me is to flee to the land of the Philistines; Saul will then give up hunting me throughout the territory of Israel, and I will escape him.”
There is likely an ironic use of the term “repugnant” (באש) here. It appears only once previously, in the Saul narrative, when Saul deals a powerful military blow against the Philistines, eliciting the very same reaction of repugnance from them—וְגַם נִבְאַשׁ יִשְׂרָאֵל בַּפְּלִשְׁתִּי, “and Israel had become repugnant to the Philistines” (13:4). David’s actions here constitute an ironic reversal of that previous incident. David, an Israelite, soon to be king, has deceptively created the impression of repugnance of Israel with him, thereby endearing himself to the Philistines.
McCarter (1 Samuel, 415) notes that the ʿebed ʿolam was “a category of bondsman which seems to have involved some kind of formal and voluntary acceptance of status by a servant, who thereby surrendered his chances of freedom forever.”
At the same time, Achish’s “right” resonates with David’s previous “right,” which entailed the slaughter of large numbers of Philistines. While convinced of David’s loyalty, Achish may also be foreshadowing his own demise.
Scholars studying the rhetoric of the narrative of David’s time spent in the Philistine camp tend to focus on how it defends David’s actions. Niels P. Lemche, for example, argues: “The whole section dealing with David’s service to the Philistines bears the stamp of the author’s endeavors to acquit David of charges of treachery as well as of participation in the events leading to the death of Saul.” See Niels P. Lemche, “David’s Rise,” JSOT 10 (1978): 2–25, at p. 13. He overlooks, however, the subtle, sustained critique of David as representing the future of the monarchy in Israel.
This episode is a striking example of details which Halpern considers a series of admissions combined to effect “denials” of damning accusations against David by his opponents. As Halpern summarizes the combined effect of all these admissions, “The text effectively concedes all the most damaging information one could conceive in order to rescue David from a single suspicion: that he was instrumental in the defeat and death of Saul. So much admission, for so small, and yet so exquisite, a denial.” See Halpern, David’s Secret Demons, 80–81.
Mckenzie, King David, 103, offers a different view, arguing that the narrative characterizes David’s actions here as admirable: “David’s capable handling of this crisis [with the Amalekites] contrasts with Saul’s utter collapse [against the Philistines].”
This “law” is a primary exhibit to which scholars appeal in the debate as to whether the Israelite king possessed legislative powers. See the arguments for and against in Keith Whitelam, The Just King: Monarchical Judicial Authority in Ancient Israel (Sheffield: JSOT Press, 1979), 212–214.
In a full-length study of the phrase “until this day” (עד היום הזה), translated here as “continuing to the present day,” Jefferey Geoghegan demonstrates that it reflects both a unified geographical southern perspective and a unified temporal pre-exilic perspective. Particularly pertinent to my argument here is his claim that it is employed “several times to indicate the ongoing existence of political realities relating to ancient Israel.” He lists 1 Samuel 30:25 as the establishment of laws pursuant to domestic policies. See his The Time, Place, and Purpose of the Deuteronomistic History: The Evidence of “Until This Day,” Brown Judaic Studies 347 (Providence, RI: Brown Judaic Studies, 2006), 57–58.
The ironic subversion of law here testifies to David’s corruption of what the throne stands for, since the administration of justice is as important a royal prerogative as leading the people in battle and securing the state’s political integrity. See A.R. Johnson, “Hebrew Conceptions of Kingship,” in Myth, Ritual and Kingship, ed. S.H. Hooke (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1958), 204–235, at pp. 206–207.
See Robert Alter’s note in his translation of this verse: “The verb piger may be related to the noun peger, corpse, and so would have the sense of “dead tired”” (The David Story: A Translation with Commentary of 1 and 2 Samuel [New York: W. W. Norton and Company, 1999], 185).
The Septuagint version is even more biting, adding “your corpse” to the Philistines’.
Compounding the irony is the fact that the strongest statement of “law” in the book of Samuel mandates the distribution of goods among both the living and the “dead.”
Since David was in service to the Philistines when they were at war with the Israelites, scholars have suggested that David was complicit in the death of Saul. See for instance Meir Malul, “Was David Involved in the Death of Saul on the Gilboa Mountain?” Revue Biblique 103 (1996): 517–545.
Likewise, Saul’s gruesome dismemberment after his death (1 Sam 31:8–10) recalls the dismemberment of the concubine (Judg 19:29), which provoked civil war among the Israelite tribes at the end of Judges (ch. 20).
Yairah Amit argues that Judges 19–21 constitutes a hidden polemic against Saul, preparing the reader for David’s usurpation of the monarchy from Saul. This last sentence in Judges could also be the linchpin in a hidden polemic against David and the institution of the monarchy altogether, and not only against Saul as Amit has postulated. See her “Literature in the Service of Politics: Studies in Judges 19–21,” in Politics and Theopolitics in the Bible and Postbiblical Literature, ed. H.G. Reventlow et al. (Sheffield: JSOT Press, 1994), 28–40.