Orthodoxy and the Challenge of Biblical Criticism

Series

Orthodoxy and the Challenge of Biblical Criticism

Orthodox Solutions Thus Far

SBL Style

Click to copy

"Orthodox Solutions Thus Far." TheTorah.com, March 25, 2014. https://www.thetorah.com/article/orthodox-solutions-thus-far.

APA Style

Click to copy

"Orthodox Solutions Thus Far" (2014, March 25). TheTorah.com. https://www.thetorah.com/article/orthodox-solutions-thus-far

Orthodox Solutions Thus Far

Rabbi Mordechai Breuer giving a shiur, Bayit VeGan, Jerusalem. Wikimedia

Categories:

Modern Faith

Published: March 25, 2014

|

Last Updated: September 7, 2026

  1.  As he puts it: “the power of these inferences, based on solid argument and internally consistent premises, will not be denied by intellectually honest persons” – see Mordechai Breuer, “The Study of Bible and the Primacy of the Fear of Heaven: Compatibility or Contradiction?” in Modern Scholarship in the Study of Torah: Contributions and Limitations, edited by Shalom Carmy (Northvale, N.J.L Jason Aronson, 1996), p. 161

  2.   Consonant with this policy, the departments of biblical studies at Bar Ilan University and Yeshiva University – to the best of my knowledge – still continue to teach higher criticism only as applied to the Prophets and later works, but not with regard to the five books of Moses.  A similar observation can be made with regard to censorship of higher criticism in the dept. of biblical studies at Bar Ilan university, alongside inclusion of a course on Judaism and the challenge of feminism (highlighting the male perspective of Scripture) in their dept. of gender studies. 

  3.   In personal communication

  4.  By “modernist” I refer to a worldview based on the assumption of rigid and stable notions of truth, supported by a universal, neutral and objective rationality that serves as their justification.

  5.   The Austrian-born rabbi and Torah scholar, David Zvi Hoffman, was a prominent initiator of this approach.  For more recent examples, see Yaacov Shavit and Mordechai Eran, The Hebrew Bible Reborn: From Holy Scripture to the Book of Books: A History of Biblical Culture and the Battles over the Bible in Modern Judaism, translated by Chaya Naor (Berlin: Walter de Gruyter, 2007), pp, 423-434, under the sub-heading “Orthodox bible criticism in Eretz Israel”.  Many of these responses rely on the findings of various Jewish biblical scholars such as Moshe Zvi Segal, Naftali Herz Tur-Sinai, Umberto Cassuto and Yehezkel Kaufman who objected to Wellhausen’s documentary hypothesis, despite the fact that their conclusions did not necessarily confirm the notion of a one-time revelation to Moses (ibid, pp. 389-395); see also Barukh J. Schwartz, “The Pentateuch as Scripture and the Challenge of Biblical Criticism: Responses among Modern Jewish Thinkers and Scholars”, in Jewish Concepts of Scripture: A Comparative Introduction, edited by Benjamin D. Sommer (New York: NYU Press, 2012), pp. 203-229; Asaf Yedida, Bikoret Mevukeret: Alternativot Ortodoxiyot le-“Mada Hayadut”1873-1956  (Tel Aviv: Mosad Bialik, 2013);  Amnon Bazak, Ad Hayom Hazeh (Tel Aviv: Yediot Aharonot, 2013).

  6.  Maimonides, Guide for the Perplexed II, chapter 25

  7.  Eliezer Berkovits’ distinction between Torah-authentic and Torah-tolerated ideals is one example of this approach – idem,Jewish Women in Time and Torah (Hoboken: Ktav 1990)

  8.  Mordechai Breuer, “The Study of Bible” (supra, n. 7)

  9.  David Weiss-Halivni, Peshat and Drash (New York: Oxford University Press, 1991), pp. 89-154; idem, Revelation Restored: Divine Writ and Critical Responses (Boulder, Colo.: Westview, 1997).

  10.  For more extensive discussion of this concept, which in a Jewish context represents a radical extension of R. Ishmael’s original pronouncement that “the Torah speaks in the language of man” (i.e., that the Torah contains some expressions and literary flourishes that should be understood as colloquialisms and taken at face value), see: Stephen D. Benin, The Footprints of God: Divine Accommodation in Jewish and Christian Thought (Albany 1993)

  11.  For one of the most recent efforts, see www.thetorah.com, a site which attempts to integrate traditional Torah study with the findings of biblical scholarship.