When and Where the Israelites Dwelt in Sukkot
Biblical narratives describe the Israelites living in tents in the wilderness and make no mention of sukkot, “booths.” So when and where did God “settle the Israelite people in booths”(Leviticus 23:43)? The answer: Kadesh! Although Israel journeys through the wilderness for forty years, they arrive at Kadesh early on and dwell there for more than thirty-five years.
123rf
Published: May 18, 2016
|
Last Updated: September 7, 2026
Benjamin W. Bacon, The Triple Tradition of The Exodus (London and Hartford: The Students Publishing Company, 1894), p. 237.
Others have noted as well that booths are not suitable to the biblical description; see, for example, Menachem Ben Asher’s comment, in his article, “,כי בסכות הושבתי את בני ישראל” in which he observes:
ועדיין יש לתמוה: האומנם בסוכות ישבו ישראל במדבר? והרי מסופר על מגוריהם באוהלים כדרכם של נוודי מדבר שצורת מגוריהם מאפשרת להם קיפול של האוהל לפני כל מסע והקמתו בכל מקום חנייה.
See: Menashe Harel, South Sinai (Jerusalem 1971), 88–90 [Hebrew].
For detailed discussion of this midrash, see Jeffrey Rubenstein’s TABS essay, “The Sukkah and Its Symbolism,” and the TABS essay, “The Sukkot Enigma: Knowing Why We Sit in the Sukkah.”
David Frankel deals with this problem in his TABS essay, “How and Why Sukkot Was Linked to the Exodus,” but takes a different approach.
[6] The term ימים can mean both “days” and “years.” See, for example, the phrase שנתים ימים (“two years”) in Gen 41:1 and other places, or the phrase מימים ימימה (“from year to year”) in Exod 13:10 and other places.
[7] In my view, this Kadesh is a reference to Petra and not Ein el-Qudeirat, but the matter is not critical for the argument in this piece. For more on this, see my TABS essays, “Solving the Problem of Kadesh in the Wilderness of Paran,” and “Locating Beer Lahai Roi.”
Admittedly, Num 33:36 uses the verb ח-נ-ה, but this is a stylized text which always uses the same formula. Num 22:9 also uses the term ח-נ-ה for the stops along the way. This is because the entire passage is picturing the travelling and describing its rhythm, even long stops (ימים) are just stops. The Kadesh tradition, however, envisions Israel settling the place for decades; this is something else entirely.
See Norman K. Gottwald, The Tribes of Yahweh (Maryknoll: Orbis Books, 1979), 512–530.
The major part of Jephthah’s speech (Judg 11:16–22) depends on the Sihon narrative of E, and even utilizes some lost E passages preserved nowhere else. See my forthcoming piece on the haftarah of Parashat Chukkat for details.
Lev 23 is part of H, a later work added onto P, and would have been familiar with Num 20 and the Priestly itinerary. Moreover, as the latest layer of the Pentateuch, it is likely that H was even familiar with D, and thus, would have known all three presentations of the Kadesh tradition. Thus it is reasonable to imagine H making reference to this tradition to explain the law of sukkah even if it was placing this law earlier than the narrative. (Editor’s Note: For another example of such a phenomenon, see the reference in Exodus 12:15 to the mitzvah of matzah which comes before the Israelites leave Egypt in a hurry and are unable to bake bread in 12:39, the ostensible reason for the mitzvah. ZIF)
See similarly several modern scholars, e.g.: Baruch Levine, Numbers 1-20: A New Translation with Introduction and Commentary (Anchor Bible 4a; Doubleday, 1993), 488; George B. Gray, A Critical and Exegetical Commentary on NUMBERS (ICC; Edinburgh 1903), 257–260; Samuel R. Driver, An Introduction to the Literature of the Old Testament(Cleveland: World Publishing Co., 1896), 32–33.
For more on Aaron’s death in Deuteronomy, see my TABS essay: “Why Deuteronomy has an Account of Aaron’s Death in the Wrong Place.”
For a detailed discussion of this text from a source critical perspective, see David Frankel’s TABS essay, “The Grain and Pomegranates of Mei Merivah.” As the reader will see, Frankel and I are in agreement on some matters and not others.
[15] Haran claims that all descriptions of ecstatic prophesies belong to E, see: M. Haran, The Biblical Collection, vol. 2 (Jerusalem: Bialik 2004), 157 [Hebrew]; Martin Noth assigns all appearances of “active” Miriam to J, see: Martin Noth, Numbers: A Commentary, (OTL; trans. J.D. Martin; Philadelphia: Westminister 1968), pp. 93–94, 144–145.
The incident took place at the Tent of Meeting that appears in E only; Aaron and Miriam refers to themselves as prophets whom God talks to (Num 12:2). That reference fits the E conception described in the previous note. Reference to that affliction in Deuteronomy (24:9) also supports the identification of this story with E, since the author of D used E as his main source.
For the argument that Miriam was originally not understood as Moses’ sister and that the sister in Exod 2 is someone else, see Isaac Sassoon’s TABS essay, “Moses, Aaron, and Miriam: Were They Siblings?” and Tamar Kamionkowski’s TABS essay, “Will the Real Miriam Please Stand Up?”
Moses’ family is mentioned in two genealogical lists. Both belong to P. On one list, Miriam is not mentioned at all (Exod 6:20). Although she is mentioned in the other list (Num 26:59) she has just a name with no real life attached to it.
For the identification of this passage as an E text, see my TABS essay: “Why Deuteronomy has an Account of Aaron’s Death in the Wrong Place.”
Here is where I part ways with Frankel (“Grain and Pomegranates”), as he sees the phrase, “the people stayed at Kadesh” as the beginning of the E (or non-Priestly) text, and I see this as still part of the Priestly text. Frankel sees Kadesh as a short version of Kadesh-barnea. As the arrival at Kadesh(-barnea) was already noted in P (Num 13:26aβ) he couldn’t assign the arrival at Kadesh (Num 20:1aβ) to P. I see the exact wording of E’s arrival at Kadesh in Judg 11:16b, therefore I can’t assign Num 20:1aβ to E.
Compare Exod 16:1, 19:1; Num 10:11, 33:3, 38b.
Kibroth-hattaavah, Hazeroth, Rithma, Rimmoin-perez, Libnah, Rissah, Kehelath, Mount Shepher, Haradah, Makheloth, Tahat, Terah, Mithkah, Hashmonah, Moseroth, Bene-jaakan, Hor-haggidgad, Jotbath, Abronah, Ezion-geber, Kadesh.
Rowley calculates that it would have taken the Israelites only two years to get from Egypt to Jordan, see: H.H. Rowley, From Joseph to Joshua, Biblical Traditions in The Light of Archaeology, Oxford: Oxford University, 1950, pp. 106, 133.
See: Alan H. Gardiner, “The Ancient Military Road Between Egypt and Palestine,” JEA 6 (1920): 99–116.
Menachem Ben Asher, in his above referenced article, comes to a similar conclusion:
אם אנו מתרשמים שבאותן שלושים ושמונה שנים של עונש נדדו אבותינו במדבר כמעט ללא מנוחה, באה התורה ואומרת: “בסכות הושבתי את בני ישראל”. הם לא נדדו עם אוהליהם כנוודי מדבר, אלא חנו ימים רבים במקום אחד, ושם בנו לעצמם סוכות, שהן דיור קבוע למחצה, לשהות בהן זמן רב, כנאמר: “ותשבו בקדש ימים רבים, כימים אשר ישבתם” (דב’ א:מו), ללמדנו שגם אם נדונו אבותינו לשנים רבות של חיי מדבר כעונש על חטאם החמור, נהג ה’ עמהם ברחמים.