Prophet by Swiss (colorized)-French artist Théophile Alexandre Steinlen, 1902. National Gallery of Art
Can a False Prophet Perform Miracles?
According to Deuteronomy, a false prophet who has no message from God, and advocates worshiping other gods, can still successfully perform miracles and predict the future.
Published: August 7, 2018
|
Last Updated: September 7, 2026
B. Sanhedrin 90a. The story of the false prophet Hananiah ben Azur is found in Jeremiah chapter 28.
Ibn Ezra does not identify whose ideas he is referring to, and scholarship, to the best of my knowledge, has not identified his sources.
An allusion to the phrase מגנבי דברי הנביאים “the prophets who steal My [God’s] words from one another” (Jer 23:30).
A similar argument was later offered by Maimonides in Mishneh Torah, Yesodei ha-Torah 8:1. Maimonides argues there that miracles are not a reason to believe and that even the miracles that Moses performed were not what caused him to be believed.
An allusion to the language of Maimonides, Mishneh Torah, Teshuvah 10:3 (10:2 in some editions).
Ma’aseh Nissim: Commentary on the Torah, ed. by Howard Kreisel (Jerusalem: Mekize Nirdamim, 2000), p. 453.
Which is called an אות in that same verse.
The impressive Mikraot Gedolot on the website alhatorah.org prefers reading here שעזרו, not שעזבו, and cites some manuscript evidence for this reading. Nevertheless, the reading שעזבו is also attested in manuscripts and is found in most standard texts and in Mikraot Gedolot Ha-keter, edited by Menahem Cohen. Moreover, the suggestion that God is helping the false prophet (שעזרו), does not fit well with ibn Ezra’s interpretation.
Already five hundred years ago Abarbanel dismissed ibn Ezra’s understanding of the test involved in false prophets – that even though they have no special powers we can still say that they constitute a test from God since God allows such people to live – using two different trivializing terms: וכל זה איננו שוה (all of this is worthless) and הוא טענה בטלה (this explanation is null).
Rashbam is explaining that Deut 18:13 clarifies the idea behind the previous verses. The reason to avoid soothsayers, diviners etc… is to remain wholehearted with God.
Editor’s note: For more on “permissible divination” in the Torah, see Jonathan Stökl, “Ancient Israelite Divination: Urim Ve-Tummim, Ephod, and Prophecy,” TheTorah.com (2017); Yoel S., “The Urim Ve-Tummim,” TheTorah.com (2014).
This text of Bekhor Shor’s comment on Deut 13:4 is found in Mikraot Gedolot Ha-keter, edited by Menachem Cohen.
Theoretically we could read Bekhor Shor as listing the three possible ways that Jesus performed his signs: magic, sleight of hand, or plagiarism. I consider this understanding unlikely. I think Bekhor Shor is certain that Jesus’s signs were performed through magic, as claimed in the Talmud (uncensored version of b. Sanhderin 107b) and in the old Jewish parody of Jesus’ life, Toledot Yeshu. Here he is just listing three kinds of false prophets who must be ignored: those who use magic, as Jesus did, and those who use sleight of hand or theft.
As Bekhor Shor explains in the continuation of his remark, he is referring to the possibility of a false prophet plagiarizing from a true prophet, noted in ibn Ezra’s first explanation, above.
Similarly, see e.g. his comments on Gen 1:26 (against the belief in the Trinity) and Num 12:8 (against Christian allegorizing).
See e.g. Elazar Touitou, Exegesis in Perpetual Motion: Studies in the Pentateuchal Commentary of Rabbi Samuel ben Meir [Heb.] (Ramat-Gan: Bar Ilan Univeristy Press, 2003), esp. pp. 34-45; and the introduction to my Peirush ha-Rashbam al ha-Torah (Jerusalem: Chorev, 2009), esp. pp. 25-29.
See e.g. his comments to Gen 49:10 or to Exod 20:13.
See e.g. his commentary to Exod 3:22.
See similarly Bekhor Shor’s comment to Deut 18:13 where he directly insults Jesus’ allegedly dubious parentage.
For more on this subject, see Yedida Eisenstat, “Does Rashi’s Torah Commentary Respond to Christianity,”TheTorah.com (2018).
Itamar Kislev, “‘Exegesis in Perpetual Motion’: The Short Commentary of Ibn Ezra as a Source for Rashbam in his Commentary on the Pentateuch” (Heb.), Tarbiz 79 (2011), 413-438. The term “short commentary” means his standard commentary on the Torah but not his longer commentary on Exodus, the one printed in most versions of Mikraot Gedolot. According to many scholars, the “short commentary” was written by ibn Ezra in Italy, before Rashbam wrote his commentary on the Torah.
The exception is the University of Chicago scholar Norman Golb. See his The Jews in Medieval Normandy: A Social and Intellectual History (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1998).
Thirty years ago, I wrote an article contrasting Rashbam and ibn Ezra: “Tradition or Context: Two Exegetes Struggle with Peshat,” in From Ancient Judaism to Modern Israel: Intellect in Quest of Understanding: Essays in Honor of Marvin Fox, vol. 3 (eds., Jacob Neusner, Ernest M. Frierichs, and Nahum Sarna; Atlanta, 1989), 173-186. I hope to revisit the topic soon in a new academic article.
See Uriel Simon’s epilogue to Yesod mora vesod Torah: An Annotated Critical Edition, by Joseph Cohen and Uriel Simon, second revised and enlarged edition (Ramat Gan: Bar-Ilan University Press, 2007), pp. 213-230.
In this sense, the dispute between Rashbam and ibn Ezra about false prophets has the same underlying principle as the dispute between them about how to interpret the peshat of biblical verses that seem to contradict halakhah. Despite the fact that ibn Ezra was willing to innovate in many ways in his Torah commentary, he avoided interpretations that would have the Torah saying something that halakhah opposes. Rashbam has no such qualms and often interprets the peshat in a way that contradicts halakhah. Compare for example their interpretations of Lev 21:2-4. While the rabbis taught that a kohen (priest) may attend his wife’s funeral (actually claiming that he must), Rashbam does not hesitate to say that the peshat of the verses is that a kohen should not. Ibn Ezra, on the other hand, writes explicitly that that could not be the peshat of the verses. For a list of passages that Rashbam interprets in a way that contradicts halakhah, see the index to my Peirush ha-Rashbam al ha-Torah (Jerusalem: Chorev, 2009), pp. 532-533, s.v. פשט: הסבר בצורה שסותרת את ההלכה. For an analysis of some examples, see Zev Farber, “Can the Torah Contradict Halacha?” TheTorah.com (2014) and the introduction to my Peirush ha-Rashbam, pp. 16-18.