Why Moses Lost the High Priesthood

Ibn Ezra’s Secret of the Priesthood.

SBL Style

Click to copy

"Why Moses Lost the High Priesthood." TheTorah.com, February 22, 2024. https://www.thetorah.com/article/why-moses-lost-the-high-priesthood.

APA Style

Click to copy

"Why Moses Lost the High Priesthood" (2024, February 22). TheTorah.com. https://www.thetorah.com/article/why-moses-lost-the-high-priesthood

Why Moses Lost the High Priesthood

Moses and Aaron, Jan Luyken, 1694 (adapted) . Rijksmuseum

Categories:

Tetzaveh

Published: February 22, 2024

|

Last Updated: September 7, 2026

  1. For a modern critical explanation of the relationship between the Aaronide priesthood and a possible Mushite (i.e. from Moses) priesthood, see Mark Leuchter, “Who Were the Levites?” TheTorah (2017).

  2. That is, Moses wore the plain linen garments that were the garb of the regular priests (Exod 29:8-9).  In Exod 28:2 Moses is commanded to “Make sacral vestments for your brother Aaron…” so presumably Aaron was to be the first to wear the high priest’s special garments, not Moses.

  3. The Vatican 120–121 MS here has ואני “and I” which is a scribal error. All other printings and MSS have והוא “and he.”

  4. A similar midrash appears in Leviticus Rabbah 11:6, where the rabbis determine homiletically that at the burning bush Moses refused his call for seven days, which established seven days as the period for which he would serve as high priest before Aaron took over.   

  5. The Torah has already introduced us to Aaron (Exod 4:14), to Aaron’s children (Exod 6:23) and to the notion of an Israelite priesthood (Exod 19:22-24).  It is not until now, however, that we are told that the Aaronides will be the dynastic Israelite priests.

  6. See Arnold Ehrlich, Mikra ki-Pheshuto (New York: KTAV, 1969 [repr. of 1899]), 1.191. Ibn Ezra is taking the directive הקרב/bring forward to be conceptual rather than spatial (Hebrew and English each allow both senses), presumably because the ensuing instructions regarding the priestly vestments do not involve Aaron or his sons advancing to any location; a chapter later Moses will in fact be instructed to physically lead Aaron forward (Exod 29:4-5), though this will not take place until Lev 8:6-9.  The correct meaning of hakrev here may be “induct,” echoed in Lev 7:35; see Jacob Milgrom, Leviticus 1-16 (Anchor Bible; NY: Doubleday, 1991), 434.

  7. Scattered throughout his writings on Scripture are select commentaries that Ibn Ezra terms “sodot,” secrets.  Some of these are heterodox teachings that ibn Ezra conveys cryptically to his readers in the style of other Jewish and general esoteric writers. Ibn Ezra’s “Secret of the Twelve” is perhaps the best known of this type of secret; see Zev Farber, “Editorial Comments in the Opening Chapters of Deuteronomy and Ibn Ezra’s Secret,” TheTorah (2013). These secrets often end with the postscript, “…and the wise will understand!” and/or “…and the wise will keep silent!”  Other secrets of ibn Ezra contain ideas that are less theologically dangerous but nonetheless are outside the realm of generally accepted Jewish ideas of his day. I am grateful to Dr. Sara Labaton for providing me with this and other important information about ibn Ezra’s methodology. Sometimes, ibn Ezra’s secrets have the playful feel of a modern mystery novel, with clues scattered throughout his work to entertain and engage the reader. (Prof. Martin Lockshin, personal communication; I thank him for introducing me to the Secret of the Priesthood and for his insights that I have incorporated into this essay.) For another such example, see Zev Farber, “At 33, You Will Discover Azazel’s Secret,” TheTorah (2023).

  8. Genealogies in the Bible generally mention male lineage only, and the inclusion of a named woman is a sign that she is important. See, e.g., Antje Labah and Ehud Ben Zvi, “Observations on Women in the Genealogies of 1 Chronicles 1-9,” Biblica 84.4 (2003): 457–478.

  9. Some versions read בעבור כבוד הכהונה “because of the honor of the priesthood” but this is dittography from בעבור כבוד אלעזר “because of the honor of Eleazar” a few words earlier.

  10. This is the only mention of Elisheba in the Bible. 

  11. Num 1:7, 2:3, 7:12, 17, 10:4.

  12. The manuscripts and printed versions have two opposite expansions here. Vatican 110–111 and Munich 95 have the tribes fighting over who will get to go first (like Rabbi Meir), while the Vilna and Venice printed versions plus the genizah fragment T-S C 2.23+ have each tribe refusing to go first until Nahshon jumps. (Oxford 2675 has the former text, but is amended with brackets on the Friedberg site to read like the latter.) The former reading works poorly with the derasha, which sees Judah as positive in comparison with the negative behavior of other tribes.

  13. The text continues by reading Nahshon’s behavior as the backdrop to Psalm 69. See also the 11th cent. Numbers Rabbah 12:26, 13:7.

  14. See Exodus 18:26 and Deuteronomy 1:17.

  15. Ibn Ezra wrote two commentaries on Exodus, presumably for two separate patrons who had commissioned him.  To differentiate, scholars label one the “short” and the other the “long” commentary. This clue to the Secret of the Priesthood is found in ibn Ezra’s short commentary, the others are found in the long commentary. 

  16. See ibn Ezra’s gloss to the verse commanding the appointment of judges and court officers:

    אבן עזרא דברים טז:יח אע״פ שכל מצוה ומצוה עומדת בפני עצמה יש כדמות דרש להדבק הפרשיות
    Ibn Ezra Deut 16:18 Even though each law stands on its own, there is a type of midrashic reason for why the pericopes are connected.

    Cf. b. Berachot 63a.

  17. In his commentary on this verse, ibn Ezra adds the sin of rebellion against God while the plain meaning of the verse is that the child’s disobedience is towards his parents; ibn Ezra may be forcing this point to make the case for the Secret of the Priesthood. This is another reason he connects this to the story of the blasphemer.

  18. Strickman & Silver, following several supercommentaries, suggest that the issue here is the loose morals of the woman, Shelomith daughter of Dibri:“Shelomith fornicated with an Egyptian. A woman of such questionable morals gave birth to a son who cursed God.” H. Norman Strickman & Arthur M. Silver, Ibn Ezra’s Commentary On The Pentateuch: Deuteronomy (New York: Menorah Publishing Company, 2001), 150. This does not seem correct to me, as the matter at hand (and the Secret of the Priesthood itself) concerns worship of foreign deities, not sexual morality.  

  19. The text reads:

    במדבר כה:ז וַיַּרְא פִּינְחָס בֶּן אֶלְעָזָר בֶּן אַהֲרֹן הַכֹּהֵן וַיָּקָם מִתּוֹךְ הָעֵדָה וַיִּקַּח רֹמַח בְּיָדוֹ. כה:ח וַיָּבֹא אַחַר אִישׁ יִשְׂרָאֵל אֶל הַקֻּבָּה וַיִּדְקֹר אֶת שְׁנֵיהֶם אֵת אִישׁ יִשְׂרָאֵל וְאֶת הָאִשָּׁה אֶל קֳבָתָהּ וַתֵּעָצַר הַמַּגֵּפָה מֵעַל בְּנֵי יִשְׂרָאֵל.
    Num 25:7 When Phinehas, son of Eleazar son of Aaron the priest, saw this, he left the assembly and, taking a spear in his hand, 25:8 he followed the Israelite into the chamber and stabbed both of them, the Israelite and the [Midianite] woman, through the belly. Then the plague against the Israelites was checked.
  20. Judah Leib Krinsky in his supercommentary to ibn Ezra, Mechokekei Yehudah, ad loc. suggests that ibn Ezra is extrapolating from the word לו, to him, that is, to him and not to another brother; this would parallel Ibn Ezra’s exegesis of the word הקרב as explained at the beginning of this essay.  Ibn Ezra hedges (“ויתכן שהיו בנים אחרים לאלעזר”) probably because the genealogies of 1 Chron 5:30 [6:4] and 6:35 [6:50] do not list other children of Eleazar, but ibn Ezra is likely correct and the genealogies list only the relevant son who carried on the dynasty. 

  21. Ibn Ezra specifies that it is the high priesthood that is gifted to Phinehas; presumably his putative brothers would have continued to serve as regular priests.  This is contra b. Zevachim 101b, לא נתכהן פינחס עד שהרגו לזמרי, expounded by Rashi in his commentary to Num 25:13, which asserts that Phinehas would not have been a priest at all were it not for his zealous act and God’s reward.  The Talmud and Rashi here argue that it is precisely the issue of genetic transmission that would have otherwise excluded Phinehas from priestly dynasty, which dovetails with ibn Ezra’s thesis.  By saying that Phinehas was given the high priesthood, Ibn Ezra may have wished to establish a stronger parallel with Aaron and Moses who were both high priests, or he may have simply felt that it is the peshat. See Samuel David Luzzatto to Num 25:13.

  22. The word play is dividing the name Puti-el into two parts: “puti” is understood as pitem, “he fattened [calves]” and “el” which means “god” refers to Jethro’s gods. See also b. Sotah 43a; b. Sanhedrin 82b; Exodus Rabbah §67. The Talmud also rejects this interpretation in favor of Putiel being a reference to Joseph שפיטפט ביצרו “who brushed aside [pitpet] his sexual inclination.”